2003-01-09 Inserts
I
H FLOYD
Calhoun County Commissioner, Precinct #3
Mailing Address:
24627 State Hwy 172.
Port Lavaca. TX 77979
Office Location:
24627 State Hwy 172.
Olivia. Texas
Office (361) 893-5346
Fax (361) 893-5309
Horne (361) 552-4574
Mobile (361) 920-5346
January 06, 2003
Judge M. Pfeifer
211S.Ann
Port Lavaca, TX. 77979
RE: CALHOUN COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' COURT, JANUARY 09, 2003
REQUESTED AGENDA ITEM
Dear Judge Pfeifer:
Please add the following item to the Agenda for the captioned court session:
-
"Discuss and take necessary action to pass a resolution in support of protecting
Calhoun County bays and coastal waters from pollution and any other detrimental
activities."
A copy of the resolution and other pertinent information will be provided to each member
of the court prior to our session for their review and comment.
:;;~~
H. Floyd
cc: Commissioner R. Galvan
Commissioner M. Balajka
Commissioner K. Finster
. Mr. Bob Bolleter
File-Port Alto
J9AI-PA
.
.
.
~
...
.
Carancahua Bay Protection Association, Inc.
Port Alto Community, Calhoun County
213 County Road 307 South
Port Lavaca, Texas 77979-5350
Voice (361) 893-5273
FAX (361) 893-5394
Email: cboa@oortaltoora
January 7, 2003
Commissioner H. Floyd
Calhoun County Precinct 3
24627 State Highway l72
Port Lavaca, Texas 77979
VIA Hand Delivery
RE: Proposed Clean Water Resolution for January 9th Meeting
Dear Commissioner Floyd,
Attached please find six (6) revised packages; one for the county judge, one for each
commissioner and one for the county clerk. The package held with the white paper clip has a
loose copy of the resolution attached, which may be used as the original for signing.
The revisions to the cover letter and the resolution are those we agreed on yesterday at
the meeting at Bob Bolleter's office.
Each package contains the following:
1. A cover letter from Bob Bolleter.
2. A copy of the proposed resolution.
3. A copy of Calhoun County Shrimpers letter by Captain Wesley Blevins to TNRCC
opposing the proposed Benner permit to discharge in Carancahua Bay.
4. A copy of the Envirorunental Defense Fund and Texas Shrimpers Association request
for contested hearing regarding the proposed Benner permit.
5. A copy of a recent letter from CBP A, which encourages participation in the upcoming
public meeting about the proposed permit.
Bob, Gus, Sophon and 1 will be at the court meeting Thursday. Bob has called Captain
Blevins and I am sending him a fax. We hope he will attend the meeting.
Thank you very much for your expert help with this matter.
Sincerely,
,.:j;. // /)
X~ /----------
-. Ken Morris
Chairman
.
Resolution Supporting Clean Waters
WHEREAS, the Calhoun County Commissioner's Court recognizes that the
bays, estuaries and offshore waters in and around Calhoun County are our most important
natural resource and that both the present and future of Calhoun County depend on these
waters being kept clean and healthy, therefore
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun County shall do
all that is within our power to protect these waters; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun
County encourages the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, Texas General
Land Office and other relevant agencies to protect Calhoun County bays, estuaries and
offshore waters; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun
County shall encourage Calhoun County citizens to become involved in law abiding and
reasonable efforts to protect Calhoun County bays, estuaries and offshore waters from
. environmental damage.
County Judge
Michael J. Pfeifer
Commissioner Precinct 1
Roger Galvan
Commissioner Precinct 2
Michael Balajka
Commissioner Precinct 3
H. Floyd
Commissioner Precinct 4
}(enJ1eth Finster
.
Date
.
Carancahua Bay Protection Association, Inc.
Port Alto Community, Calhoun County
213 County Road 307 South
Port Lavaca, Texas 77979-5350
Voice (361) 893-5273
FAX (361) 893-5394
Email: cbpa@portalto.org
January 9. 2003
Calhoun County Commissioner's Court
211 Ann Street
Port Lavaca, Texas 77979
RE: Resolution Supporting Clean Waters
Honorable County Judge and County Commissioners,
We respectfully ask the Calhoun County Commissioner's Court to consider and adopt the
attached resolution supporting clean waters.
.
Why now? A public meeting called by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality
for January 14,2003 in Port Lavaca appears to be attracting widespread attention. Mr. Ronald
Benner of Palacios has applied for a permit to discharge shrimp farm waste water into
Carancahua Bay. That application has prompted several important groups to voice their
opposition. Those groups include our 300 plus petition signers, Coastal Conservation
Association (formally called GCCA), the Environmental Defense Fund with 18,000 Texas
members, and the association of Calhoun County Shrimpers as noted in an attached Jetter from
Captain Wesley Blevins of Seadrift.
The Victoria Advocate has expressed interest in doing an article about the controversy.
You will recall that Louise Popplewell had a front-page article about a previous Benner failure to
protect the environment.
Mr. Belmer proposes discharging a daily average offour million (4,000,000) gallons of
shrimp farm waste water into Carancahua Bay. That is more waste water than both Port Lavaca
and Palacios combined discharge on a daily basis, and they discharge into much larger bays. We
think Mr. Benner's application raises concern because of the possibility of potential long term
environmental damage.
As an indication of our commitment to the future we have formed a Texas non-profit
corporation and gained IRS approval as a SOI(c)(3) charitable corporation. Your support of the
resolution is greatly needed as will be your continued efforts over the coming years.
.
,.<~Cj2_ '.. j'"
// <" ~,.~:)'-;1i~.:..~ ...
.'_-=-~'l;->:: ",(...__. ~/.-,...
Bob Bolleter
Director
.
Resolution Supporting Clean Waters
WHEREAS, the Calhoun County Commissioner's Court recognizes that the
bays, estuaries and offshore waters in and around Calhoun County are our most important
natural resource and that both the present and future of Calhoun County depend on these
waters being kept clean and healthy, therefore
BE IT RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun County shall do
all that is within our power to protect these waters; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun
County encourages the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, Texas General
Land Office and other relevant agencies to protect Calhoun County bays, estuaries and
offshore waters; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Commissioner's Court of Calhoun
County shall encourage Calhoun County citizens to become involved in law abiding and
reasonable efforts to protect Calhoun County bays, estuaries and offshore waters from
. environmental damage.
County Judge
Michael J. Pfeifer
Commissioner Precinct I
Roger Galvan
Commissioner Precinct 2
Michael Balajka
Commissioner Precinct 3
H. Floyd
Commissioner Precinct 4
Kenneth Finster
.
Date
i
.
.
.
-
CALHOUN COUNTY SHRIMPERS
,~\'\
OPA
MAY 2.3 200?
BY ~
May 17, 2002
. L\ '1?
W 1cJ\) 0
LaDonna Casuouela
Office of the Chief Oerk MC 105
TNRCC
F.O.Box 13087
Austin, Tex,", 78711-3087
DEAR MS. CASTANUELA.
Our Organization Calhoun County TeXSls Sh1itnpers 2!C against the permit Teus
Pollutant DischaIge Elimination SYBtem Pe.cmi, No. 04001 filed by Ronald AII<n Benne.c of
Palacios, Texas, This permit should not be issued for :m obvious r=on and that is the
pmtectinn of the CaI,ncahua Bay System. This is a protected estuary b)' the State of Texas
and nothing th.at can cause a potencial daoger for this \--cry sensioye :.uea should not be
~owed. Th.i3 Ba.y .and estuary system is 3D. important patt of the economy of the coastal
region
We want (0 be ootified of any public meeting or hearing that will be held about this
discharge ptlmir.
Sincerely.
~~'~J
1:/t /. ~
~~- ~-
,
WeBley Blevins
Calhoun County Shrimpen Rt:presentath.-e
F.O.BOX 752 . SEADRIFT, TEXAS. 77983
PHONE: (361)785-7606 . FAX: (361)785.5281
\
~
.
.
.
B)F
ENVIRONMENTAL
DEFENSE FUND
October 12, 1998
Tt'.m.~ 01JiC'~
44 E:ut Ave.. Suite
Au"in. TX 78701
(5111478-5161
FlI.'((5/2) 4711.RI.JO
1l'\nl'.C'df.nr,J:
Dr. Eugenia K. Brumm
Chief Clerk, Mail Code 105
Texas Natural Resources Conservation Commission
P.O. Box 13087
Austin, TX 78711-3087 Hand Delivered
RE: Request for Hearing on Ronald A. Benner's Application
Dear Dr. Brumm
Enclosed are 12 copies of a request for hearing and comments on the application of
Ronald A. Benner to discharge pollutants to Carancahua Bay. This document is tiled on behalf
of the Environmental Defense Fund, Mr. Alber! Garrison, who is a member of EDF. and the
Texas Shrimp Association (TSA).
Please call me ifYOll require any additional information to process this request
Sincerely,
-rr'>~..e. -.1~.
Melinda E. Taylor ().
Senior Attorney
cc: Richard Lowerre
N"li""'IIH,'u'/'llwrt..,.I
257 1'....1. r\.(nu~ S'luth
N<:"~\'''l\.., t\y \(\U\il
L? 12) 50.~.210l)
Pr,'j~I'tOlJk"
6 fan.:uil Hall M:ut~''i't~~
Buslon.M.-\0210'J
{&11}n;l-,:!Wo
1-105 Ar.1pahoe ^\'~
Boulu.:r. CO SOJO:!
(303 1 440-49U l
2500 Blu~ Rid!:~ Rd.
Ral.:illh,KC11W7
~919}\~~I.:!bOl
IIl75 C\lnn...~.ti<:ul An:,., N.W.
1,''';.l.:;,hin~lOn. DC 21~)09
I:!O!JJii7-J500
56.HC-oIk-J>('A\-('.
O;.ll;land, CA 94618
('lOJ65:l.l'lOO8
100'. p<>>'.C"".....".,., Root'r<:IoI<lP....'
..li:il
iJI'
.
.
r-
.
Q~(o41~
v-iI,..,V
IN THE MA TIER OF
THE APPLlCATlON OF
RONALD A. BENNER
8
(;
8
Ii
OPA
BEfORE THE.." ,
TEXASNATURALRESORUCE
CONSER V A TION COMMISSION
WATER QUALITY PERMIT ~O.
04001
(;
PROTEST, COMMENTS. AND REOUEST FOR HEARING
TO THE HONORABLE COMMISSIONERS
THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND (EDF), MR. ALBERT GARRISON, AND
THE TEXAS SHRIMP ASSOCIATION (EDF) (Movants) respectfully file this their protest,
c.omments, and request for hearing on the application of Ronald A. Benner (Applicant), and, in
support of the request, Movants would show the following:
I. AFFECTED PERSONS
Movants will be affected adversely by the water pollutants and biological pollutants
released by the Applicant's shrimp farm to Carancahua Bay. Movants meet all relevant tests of
affected persons, including those listed in 30 T AC 855.29. They have specific interests that are
intended to be protected by Chapter 26, Texas Water Code, and that would be adversely affected
in ways not common to those of the general public.
A. Movant EOF. EOF is a nonprofit research and advocacy organizations th.t
seeks solutions to environmental problems including the conservation .nd protection ofwater,
coastal, and fishery resources of Texas, including Carancahua Bay and the area ofCarancahua
Bay into which the Applicant is and proposes to discharge. EDF has 18,000 members in Texas
including many who live on the Texas Coast and near Carancahua Bay. The interests that EDF
seeks to protect (the w.ter, coastal, and fishery resources in C.rancahu. Bay and the rights to
enjoy said resources) are germane to EDF's purposes.
In the past, EDF has t.ken a number of specific steps to reach its go.ls. including, but
not limited to:
.-
EDF published a case study on Texas shrimp fanning.,- as part of a larger document
describing the environmental effects of aquaculture in the United States - to inform
the public and government officials about the water quality and other effects of
coastal shrimp farming in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays;
EDF made a presentation at the 1998 World Aquaculture Society meeting on
sustainable shrimp farming practices;
EDF made a presentation at the Lower Laguna Madre Foundation's 1997 annual
meeting in BrownsviJle, Texas about the environmental affects of shrimp farming;
4. EDF is a member of a federal panel developing a shrimp virus ecological risk
assessment, which includes an assessment of the risks from Texas shrimp farms;
5 EDF played a key role in organizing an alliance of coastal citizens and
environmental groups to work with the 75~ Texas State Legislature to develop a
shrimp farming bill that would have provided needed environmental protection for"
Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays; and
6. EDF regularly participates in processes that allow the public to influence state and
federal environmental regulatory policies in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays.
(
.
B. Movant Albert Garrison.
Mr. Albert Garrison is a member of EDF. He is a
professional fishing guide and sport fisherman. He has fished and taken clients fishing in the
area of the Applicant's shrimp farm. He is an affected person based on his uses of the area,
which will be. adversely affected by the proposed activities of the Applicant and the issuance of
the proposed permit
While the discharge point is about 15 miles from the residence of Mr. Garrison, he, like
many fishing guides travel such distances in search of trophy class spotted seatrout, redfish,
flounder, and black drum. If a fishing guide were to travel such distances only to find the water
so murky that he or she cannot fish there, the adverse economic impacts of the discharge cannot
be denied
C. Movant TSA TSA is a non-profit corporation chanered in 19S0 to protect the
interest of its members and others. TSA noW represents over 700 maritime-registry fishing
vessels, their owners, shrimp processors and associated crews and workers that make up a total
,.-.....
population of approximately 35,000 full time employed individuals. The interest ofTSA's
.
.
r
.
"
.
members includes the protection and enhancement of the populations of the native shrimp and
the habitat of those shrimp. Harvesting of native shrimp stocks by members ofTSA and others
has a significant impact on the State's economy, producing more than $600 million per year in
revenues. In comparison, the production value of Texas' commercial shrimp farms in 1995 was
$33 million. The members ofTSA have an interest in the protection of the native shrimp from
negative impacts of operations of shrimp fanns
In the past, TSA has taken a number of specific steps to reach its goals, including, but
not limited to:
TSA has been a participant in four Texas shrimp farm TNRCC public hearings, in
1993, J 994, 1996, and 1997;
2 TSA is a member ofa federal panel developing a shrimp virus ecological risk
assessment, which includes an assessment of the risks from Texas shrimp fanns;
3 TSA played a key role in developing shrimp farming bills during the 74" and 75"
Texas State Legislature that would have provided needed environmental protection
for Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays; and
4 TSA regularly participates in processes that allow the public to influence state and
federal environmental regulatory policies- in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays
On behalf of its members, EDF and TSA seek to protect the coastal and aquatic
resources ofCarancahlla Bay. If issued, ti,e permit would allow significant degradation of the
water quality, habitat and aquatic species in Carancahua Bay.
EDF and TSA seek only actions oflhe Commission within the power of the Commission
to protect the interests of EDF and TSA and their members The participation of individual
members of the EDF and TSA is not required because the members seek only the same results as
EDF and TSA. and no specific relief to the benefit of any individual member.
'Movants allege and stand ready to prove that the discharges of Applicant will be
harmful to the water quality, habitat and aquatic species in Carancahua Bay, 'Carancahua Bay
has limited ability to disperse the water and biological pollutants from the extremely large
volumes of highly turbid and low oxygen discharges of the Applicant's farm because it is
shallow, warm and poorly circulated. 'The Applicant's proposed wastewater discharges to
~
r
.
---
.
Carancahua Bay could have negative environmental effects. 'For example, exotic shrimp
viruses could be spread to Carancahua Bay, a state designated shrimp nursery, and to wild
shrimp populations; high turbidity could kill aquatic vegetation and animals, such as sea grass
beds and oyster reefs; the bay's sportfishing potential could be diminished by high turbidity and
resultant murky water conditions; and low oxygen conditions could eliminate important aquatic
plants and animals from the Carancahua Bay ecosystem
Under both the federal and state law of standing, all Movants have sufficient basis for
standing. In Save Our Communities v. U.S. EPA, 971 F.2d 1155 (5" Cir. 1992) for example, the
Circuit Court specifically recognized that injury to a.sthetic, environmental and recreational
interests was sufficient to support standing in a water pollution case. Quoting the U.S. Supreme
Court in U.S. v S.C.R.A.P., 412 U.S. 669, 93 S. Ct. 2405 (1973), the Court also stated that the
injury need not be economic and that the threshold of injury is low for standing. Texas Courts'
require spedal injury. However, Texas laws, including TNRCC statutes, do no limit the injury
to economic ones. Ecological, scientific, recreational and other interests can be sufficient for
standing in Texas Courts (and thus agency hearings).
Finally TNRCC rules recognize that use of the impacted natural resource is part ofthe
test of an affected person. 30 T AC $55.29 (c) (5).
furthermore, Movants have special expertise to assist the Commission in evaluating the
ongoing and proposed activities of the Applicant. The Movant's interests are redressable by a
favorable ruling to change the permit to provide more restrictive discharge limitations and
require the Applicant to change its practices associated with the discharges.
II. REASONABLENESS
Movants do not seek a hearing to raise issues outside of the jurisdiction of the
Commission. Movants do not seek to raise issues other than those related to water pollution
Movants seek changes in the draft pennit. Movants seek a hearing because of the
deficiencies in the proposed permit and the history of non-compliance of the Applicant,
including the discharge of pollutants without a pennit for approximately eight years
~
.--------
.
---..
.
The hearing requests of Movants arc reasonable under all relevant factors set furth lidO
lAC 6 55.3t(b) (1).
J. The application dos not involve a pollution reduction project;
2 Neither the application nor project is mandate by Commission rules;
3. The location of the discharge is Carancahua Bay, an area that provides economic and
recreational benefits to members ofEDF and TSA;
4. Applicant has not asked to substitute an equivalent or more efficient control device;
5 These hearing requests are based on impacts to Movants directly related to water
pollution and to impacts of the operation ofa wastewater facility by Applicant;
6. Movants and the members of EDF and TSA are clearly impacted, as described
above, and those impacts are significant; and
7. 'The Applicant has operated since about 1990 without a penn it, despite the
knowledge that one was required. This constitutes a panem of egregious conduct
that demonstrates a consistent disregard for the regulatory process. The Applicant
has profited from its failure to obtain a pennit. It has not had to implement controls
that would have been required. It has not had to do the sampling and reporting that
would have been required
m. COMPETENT EVIDENCE
Movants seek a hearing and the opportunity to present their evidence in support of these
hearing requests. Movants are prepared to present testimony, including eKpert testimony about
the fact that the discharges of Applicant will adversely affect Carancahua Bay and the interests
of Movants.
IV. PROPER REQUEST
These requeSts for hearing meet all requirements oDD TAC b5S.21. They are timely
filed with the chief Clerk and are pursuant to rights to hearings authori~ed by the Texas Water
Code and the Texas Administrative Procedure Act.
v. COMMENTS
As comments, Movants provide this pleading. Movants have added an ..... in front of
each sentenCe above that Movants submit as 8 comment as a basis for the hearing requests.
~.
I
.
.
In addition, Movants submit the following comments (and additional bases for the
hearing requests).
The permit's proposed limitations established by the TNRCC do not provide
environmental safeguards adequate to protect the coastal water quality and marine
ecosystems of the Carancahua Bay ecosystem.
2. The Harlingen Shrimp Farm permit issued by the Commission in July, 1998 contains
four key protections that should be included in the Applicant's permit: I) limitations
on wastewater discharges and pollutant inputs; 2) best management practices; 3)
third-party monitoring; and 4) wastewater toxicity testing
J Movants recommend that mass-based discharge limitations (pounds of
pollutant/day) should be included in the penn it, in addition to the draft permit's
proposed concentration-based limits (milligrams of pollutant/liter of water), for
carbonaceous biochemical oxygen demand (CBOD5), ammonia-nitrogen (NH3-N),
and total suspended solids (TSS). The use of mass-based limits encourages shrimp
famlers to reduce their discharges while concentration-based limits help to avoid
excessive concentrations of pollutants in the mixing zone where the effluent is
diluted by receiving waters, Together these limitation will help the industry
minimize its risk for contributing to coastal water quality degradation problems and
introducing biological pollutants such as exotic shrimp species and shrimp diseases.
4. The draft permit allows the Applicant to discharge more water - a daily average and
maximum of2.5 and 7.5 million gallons per day (MGD), respectively - than its
operations appear to require. Movants recommend that the discharge limitation
more accurately represent the Applicant's operations. For example, the permit
limitations should reflect the seasonal nature of the discharge - maximum August
through November.
5. mRCC proposes to limit inorganic suspended solids (lSS) instead of total
suspended solids (TSS), as the agency has required on past shrimp farm permits
Movants recommend retaining the use of TSS in order to maintain a measure of
phytoplankton which is not included in a measure of ISS. Shrimp farmers cultivate
moderate to dense ph}10plankton blooms in ponds which, when discharged in large
volumes, can degrade water quality by creating turbid and low oxygen conditions.
The Environmental Protection Agency has informed TNRCC, with regards to federal
~
penn its for St. Martin's and Harlingen shrimp fanns, that "due to lack of data to
draw a correlation between TSS and !55, the Agency agrees not to replace TSS with
!55".
6. Movants recommend that toxicity testing be an enforceable condition of the penn it
to detect the presence of harmful chemicals, toxic bacteria, and other pollutants that
are not measured in the standard discharge limitations This testing should be
conducted at least once per harvest
7. Movants recommend that TNRCC allow third-party monitoring of the farm's
operations.
8 Movants recommend that TNRCC require the use of best management practices
(8MPs) as an enforceable condition of the pennit in order to prevent or minimize the
generation of pollutants, their release, and potential release from the farm to the
state's waters. BMPs for the Applicant's shrimp fann should include the following
r~quirements:
r
.
Vegetate or otherwise stabilize earthen levees and dikes to reduce TSS and
155 resulting from e~osion.
. Consider especially sensitive habitats and animals to be affected. Effluent
discharges should not negatively impact endangered species habitat, other
important habitats, or other economic or recreational uses
. Minimize routine water exchange by maintaining high pond water quality and
using supplemental aeration as needed. The daily maximum water exchange
rate between Carancahua Bay and the farm should not exceed 5% of the
farm's total volume
. Use settling ponds to cleanse wastewater before it is discharged
. Minimize use of water amendments. For example, reduce fertilizer use and
do not use lime unless fallow pond soils are acidic There should be no
wastewater discharge for at least 30 days after pond water is fertilized
. Use a feed that gives optimum growth and feed conversion at the lowest
possible protein level, has a high sinking rate, and has high water stability
. Use feeding trays instead of broadcast feeders to manage and adjust reed
inputs
.
.-
r
.
~
.
Distribute the day's ration in multiple feedings a few hours apart to improve
feed conversion and growth, and reduce accumulation of uneaten feed
. Cease feeding at least three days before harvest.
. Incorporate use of wetlands, oyster ponds, andlor fish ponds to clean or
eliminate effluent water, where appropriate
Do not remove pond sludge unless necessary. Dispose of sludge on high
ground.
Initiate and maintain biosecurity measures such as fencing and limitations of
vehicular and personnel traffic to reduce the risk of disease outbreaks and
transmission to coastal waters
Movants request timely and full response to its comments.
VI. CONCLUSIONS
WHEREFORE, Premises Considering. Movants request a hearing on the application and
that the proposed penn it be denied or revised to protect the water quality, habitat, and aquatic
life ofCarancahua Bay. Movants also seek a full and detailed response to each of the comments
Respectfully submitted,
-;vV"\. ~c.._ .k(
[. -.!Jeo. I-
-..--) .
Melinda E. Taylor
SBN 19714030
Senior Attorney
Environmental Defense Fund
44 East Avenue, Suite 304
Austin, Texas 7870 I
(512)478-5161
.j
.r
.
.
.
Carancahua Bay Protection Association, Inc.
Port Alto Community, Calhoun County
213 County Road 307 South
Port Lavaca, Texas 77979-5350
Voice (361) 893-5273
FAX (361) 893-5394
Email: cbpa(cVportalto.orq
January 6, 2003
Subject: Public Meeting of Those Concerned About a Shrimp Farm
Dumping Polluted Waste Water into Carancahua Bay
Despite what you hear on the street or read in The Pori Lavaca Wave the Carancahua Bay
shrimp farm waste water discharge application has not gone away, nor has the meeting already been
held. Apparently the talk about all this was just a smoke screen. One does not have to wonder why.
State authorities have scheduled a public meeting to discuss the application on January 14,2003;
more about that later. A copy of the public notice announcing the meeting is enclosed.
A public meeting is held to allow an exchange of ideas between opponents and proponents of
controversial projects. In other words, we will have a chance to question Ronald Benner, the
applicant, along with professionals from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ).
That agency is on record as favoring the application.
To be effective participants at the public meeting it is important to understand how it will be
structured. The meeting has two parts. The first part is called the "Open Discussion Period" and is
Dot for the record. This discussion period allows Mr. Benner and state professionals a chance to
respond to opinions and questions off the record.
The second part of the meeting is called the "Formal Comment Period" which is for the
record and will be recorded by the state. Only "relevant and material" issues raised during this
formal period will be used in the decision process. It will be necessary for you to restate opinions
and questions you brought up in the first part of the meeting if you wish them included for the record.
Opinions and questions you wish to offer in either session may be either spoken or written and
handed in. Written comments or questions for the record should include your name, address, how
you use the bay and the pennit number which is 04001. The period for public comment will be
closed at the end of the public meeting.
Why all the fuss? As you will recall, Ronald Benner of Palacios has submitted an application
to discharge a daily average flow of 4,000,000 gallons of shrimp farm waste water into Carancahua
Bay. According to his application, he could release as much as 8,000,000 gallons in one day as long
as he maintains a long term average not larger than 4,000,000. Either amount is more waste water
than many towns discharge. In fact this proposed discharge is greater than the combined discharge
from the cities of Port Lavaca and Palacios. Most of us oppose the discharge on the basis that the
waste water is essentiaJJy the "shrimp farm sewer". We think that it is a bad idea for both health and
environmental reasons. Now, also recall that it was this very same Ronald Benner who was
responsible for serious environmental infractions which included dumping lead acid batteries, used
electric motors, and shrimp net lead weights into Carancahua Bay waters adjacent to his shrimp fann.
~I
CBPA Letter 1/6/03
j
.
Benner removed most of the items after the illegal dump site was exposed by a well documented front
page article in The Victoria Advocate. Mr. Benner also received guidance concerning legal action
from the Calhoun County Sheriff and Victoria County Health Department. Unfortunately, personnel
at our very own Texas Commission on Environmental Quality chose not to do anything about the
illegal dump.
You now see the problem. We must convince the state environmental agency not to)ssue a
discharge permit when that agency has already:
1. Declared the discharge permit to be consistent with the Coastal Management Program
goals and objectives. Refer to TCEQ Notice ofthe Benner application No. 04001
dated December 4, 2002.
2. Made the declaration of consistence with plans and goals despite full knowledge that
the applicant was responsible for an illegal dump of hazardous materials into
Carancahua Bay. We do not understand why an agency responsible for protecting the
environment is not willing to penalize those who degrade it.
.
Obviously we have a fight on our hands. We must make our points at this public meeting in
order to get the state to deny the application or Mr. Benner to withdraw it; otherwise we must proceed
to the next step which is called a "Contested Case Hearing". That much more formal hearing will
come some months from now and success at that time will require the full strength that comes with
being well organized and well financed. To that end, we have formed Carancahua Bay Protection
Association, Inc. as a Texas non-profit corporation which has been granted 501(c) (3) status by IRS.
Using this entity we can receive tax deductible donations to be used to pay lawyers specializing in
this type case. In addition to our request for contested hearing on this matter Matagorda Bay
Foundation and Environmental Defense Fund have also requested a hearing. Coastal Conservation
Association is expected to issue a strong statement against the discharge very soon and we have ask
them to request a hearing also. We also have a resolution supporting clean waters before the Calhoun
County Commissioner's Court. By the way, we plan on maintaining this organization for any
possible future challenges to the bay.
As we have said before, we have several lawyers in our group who will work to keep our
legal costs at a minimum. Never the less, one environmental law firm has given us an estimate
between $3,000 and $50,000 to represent us at the contested case hearing. We had over 300 signers
of the petition, but they did not agree to pay anything, however we believe there are enough
concerned users to raise the funds needed to protect our bay. We will also pursue the availability of
grant funds to help in the bay's defense.
Now back to the immediate problem where no money is involved. Please come to this very
important first step, the "public meeting", prepared to speak up, offer written comments, or indicate
your opposition to this permit by your presence. This meeting is scheduled Tuesday, 7:00 p.m.,
January 14,2003 at the Days Inn, 2100 North Highway 35, Port Lavaca, Texas. A large turnout
will demonstrate that we are very serious about stopping this permit.
Some issues likely to be discussed in both the formal and informal parts of the meeting may
. include:
- 2 -
.
.
.
.'
CBP A Letter 1/6/03
J. Does the proposed pennit really represent good coastal management?
2. Is the financial benefit to Mr. Benner from dumping his polluted shrimp farm waste more
important than the recreational use of Carancahua Bay by hundreds of residents and users?
3. Why is TCEQ turning a blind eye to Mr. Benner's past record of operating an illegal dump
at this site?
4. What will be done to insure that there can be no discharge ofhannful disease pathogens
from this proposed site in the polluted discharge?
5. What will be done to stop the serious erosion on the bay side of the shrimp fann that
threatens massive uncontrolled release of contaminants into Carancahua Bay?
6. What measures will be implemented to insure that the peaceful environment ofCarancahua
Bay will not be fouled by noise and noxious odors?
7. How will the endangered oyster population of Carancahua Bay be protected from damage
by Benner's operation?
8. What will be done to guarantee that pollution from the shrimp fann does not hann
swimmers, fishennen or consumers of products from the bay?
9. What effect will addition of fertilizers, feed or other additives to the shrimp ponds have on
the bay?
10. Why is any discharge being pennitted when new management techniques enable
operation of a shrimp farm without discharge?
Please come and voice your opinion about these issues and other issues of concern to you. This is the
last chance to present public comment for the record since the public comment period closes at the
end of this meeting.
S incerel y,
Bob Bolleter
Diane Koerner
Sophon Lorchirachoonkul, Ph.D.
Lynn Bolleter
Gus Koerner
Ken Morris
- 3 -
,1
I
.
.
TEXAS COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Protecting Texas by Reducing and Preventing Pollution
NOTICE OF PUBLIC MEETING ON AN APPLICATION FOR
WATER QUALITY TPDES PROPOSED
PERMIT NO. 04001
APPLICATION. Ronald Alhm B~nLlct. P. O. Box 2QJ. P&la.cios, T~Xl1S 71465. has flpplied to the Texas Commission on
Environmental Quality (TCEQ) (fonnerly the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission) for a n~ permit, proposed Texas
Pollutanl Discharge Elimination System (TPDES) Permit No. 04001, to authorize the discharse ofrnaricufturc: wastewatc:r at a daily
average flow not to exceed 4,000,000 gaUons per day via Outfa)} 001. It is proposed that the mariclJlIurc facility be located where
County Road 316 meets CaranCI1hU8 Bay, approximately 3.4 mil\:5 south of the intersection of State Highways 35 and 172,lIJ1d 2.2
miles cast of the intersection of State Highway 172 and County Road 304, near tho: City QfPort Altl), Calhoun County, Texas. The
emuent is discharged to ll. county drainage ditch, then to Carancahua Bay in Segment No. 2456 of the Bays tlnd Estuaries. tl;\e county
dit~h is an unda.ssifll::d receiving water thut has no siBnificant aquatic life Use. The dcsignnled uses for Segment No. 2456 are
exceptional quality aquu.lic lit',; Use, contact {cc{(:'d\ion, and o)'sten""..tel'3. No signiticant degradation of high quality receiving waters
i~ anticipated.
The TCEQ Exccuti vc Director has prepared 8 draft pennil which. if approved, will authorize the conditions under \yhich the facility
must opcra~e. The Execut.ive Director has ~..;ew~ \h1s action for comi,lcncy with the: gOllls and policies of the Texas Coastal
Management PJogrum (CMP)in acc.ordance \"ith the regulations or the Coastal Coord!nation Council ond has determined t~at the
action is consiste!1t with th'e eMF gOllb and policies.
.
PUBLIC COMMENTIPUllLlC MEEl'lNG. A public meeting will be held and will consisl o[[wo parts, an Informal DisCU3SioQ
Period and a Formal Comment Period. DunnE the Infonna\ Discussion Period, the public is encouraged to ask. questions of the
applicanlllnd TCEQ stull' conc..:rning the application and the Executive Director'! prcliminaf)' decision, but these informal comments
mJdt' during the informal period will not be considered by the Commissioners befote rcaching a decislon on the pennit and no formal
{espol,se will be mildc:-. During the Formal Comment Period, members of the public mll}' state their fonnal comments into the official
record. A wrinen response to all tOlmllt comments \\'i\\ be pu:p<lTl:d by the Executive Director and considered by the Commissioners
before they reach a decision on the permit. A copy of the response \\ill be serlt to ea~h person who submits a formal comment or who
reque:;ted to be on the mailing list for this application and provides an address. Only relevant and materia! issues raised during the
\"orm:t\ comment period can be considered if a contested case hellring is granted.
Tb.e Public Muting u to br held:
Tuesday, Janual1' 1-1,2003 at 7:00 p.rn.
Da)'sInn
2100 N. Highwa)' JS
P01't LD'V1loCa, Te::uls 77979
INFORMATION. Citizens 8rc cn~ouragcd to submit wrihen comments anytime during' the meeting or by malt before the ineeticg
to the Otlicc of the Chief Clc:rk, TCEQ, Mail Cooe MC.I0S, P.c.>. Box 13087, Austin, TX 78711~3087. If you need more
intocmaticm, please eall the TCEQ Oili.et' ot'Public Assistance, Ton Free, aI1.800-.687-4040. General information about the TCEQ
can be fouad at our web sile at \\.\\"\>'-.fcca.stalc,LX.U:L
Further information about the llpplication mllY also be obtAined from Ronald Allen Benner at P. O. Box 263, Palacios, TeKaS 77465
Qr by calling Mr. Ronald Allen Benner at (361) 972-5818.
Issued: December 4, 2002
.
-
CALHOUN COUNTY SHRIMPERS
,~y\
OPA
MAY 2.3 2002
BY ~
M.y 17, 2002
. L\~~
to 1uJ\) Q
Lillo"". CasllUl...b
Office of the Chief Ouk MC 105
TNRCC
r.o.Box 13087
Austin, TCl<as 78711-3087
DEAR MS. CASTANUELA,
Our Organization Calhoun County Texas Shrimpers are avinst the permit Tens
Pollutant Disclwge Elin:Unation System Pet1,ut No. 04001 filed by Ronald Allen Benner of
Palacios, Tens. This pe.tmit should not be issued fot an obvious reason and that is the
protection of the C"",ncahua Bay System. This is . prote<:ted estuary by the State of Texas
~nd nothing that can cause II porco cUI danger for this very sensjtn~e ;area should not be
allowed. This "Ba.y .and estuary systeOl is an impo1'tant part of the economy of the coastal
region
We want to be notified of any public meeting or hearing that will be held about this
discblU&e pumir.
Sincerely,
V/.MLJ b/~~
WeSley Blevins
Calhoun County Shrimpers Represetlt.rive
P.O_BOX 752 . SEADRIFT, TEXAS' 77983
PHONE: (361)785-7606' FAX: (36\)785-528\
,
~
-,
B)F
ENVIRONMENTAL
DEFENSE FUND
October 12, 1998
Tr:CtuOffiC'1!
44 EaSl A..e., Suite
Austin. TX 78701
(512)478.5161
Fax (5/2) 478.8140
U'\lw.t:'df.org
Dr. Eugenia K. Brumm
Chief Clerk, Mail Code 105
Texas Natural Resources Conservation Commission
P.O. Box 13087
Austin, TX 78711-3087 Hand Delivered
RE: Request for Hearing on Ronald A. Benner's Application
Dear Dr. Brumm
Enclosed are 12 copies of a request for hearing and comments on the application of
Ronald A. Benner to discharge pollutants to Carancahua Bay. This document is filed on behalf
of the Environmental Defense Fund, Mr. Albert Garrison, who is a member ofEDF, and the
Texas Shrimp Association (TSA).
Please call me if you require any additional information to process this request
Sincerely,
-;;vv""\.J--.R... -1 c.....,Jl-.
Melinda E. Taylor ().
Senior Attorney
cc: Richard Lowerre
NlII;mwl H"l/lI'f1wr,<,n
2:'\7 \'...\. A\-('nll~ S,}ulh
Nt'"-Yn..l... t-;y 10010
(21:!l51J:'i.:?:IOII
IK75ConnC'1,:11o.:UI A,-(., N.W.
Wa.~hin~lt)ll. DC 2(X)OIJ
l!O!J 3X7-:\500
56.55 Colkg(' A\'e.
O;.lUanu, CA 9-J,/)J8
(SIO) 6511-8008
1405 Arapah~ A,'(
Booh.l.:r. CO 80J02
(30314-40.-1901
2500 Blue Ridg.: Rd.
Ral.:i~h. r-;C 21607
(919J881.2601
P"'jr'l',Obkr
6 Fan.:uil Hall Marketplace
8oslOn,MA021(N
(617)7:!J-29'16
l00.oP051.(;OtlS"""Rec.,.c:IedPape-r
1
.'
r
EDF published a case study on Texas shrimp fanning.,.. as part of a larger document
describing the environmental effects of aquaculture in the United States -to infonn
the public and government officials about the water quality and other effects of
coastal shrimp fanning in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays;
EDF made a presentation at the 1998 World Aquaculture Society meeting on
sustainable shrimp fanning practices;
EDF made a presentation at the Lower Laguna Madre Foundation's 1997 annual
meeting in Brownsville, Texas about the environmental affects of shrimp farming;
4. EDF is a member of a federal panel developing a shrimp virus ecological risk
assessment, which includes an assessment of the risks from Texas shrimp farms;
5 EDF played a key role in organizing an alliance of coastal citizens and
environmental groups to work with the 75" Texas State Legislature to develop a
shrimp farming bill that would have provided needed environmental protection for'
Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays; and
6. EDF regularly participates in processes that allow the public to influence state and
federal environmental regulatory policies in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays
r
B. Movant Albert Garrison. Mr. Albert Garrison is a member of EDF. He is a
professional fishing guide and sport fisherman. He has fished and taken clients fishing in the
area of the Applicant's shrimp farm. He is an affected person based on his uses of the area,
which will be adversely affected by the proposed activities of the Applicant and the issuance of
the proposed permit.
While the discharge point is about 15 miles from the residence of Mr. Garrison, he, like
many fishing guides travel such distances in search of trophy class spotted seatrout, redfish,
flounder, and black drum. If a fishing guide were to travel such distances only to find the water
so murky that he or she cannot fish there, the adverse economic impacts of the discharge cannot
be denied
C. Movant TSA TSA is a non-profit corporation chartered in 1950 to protect the
interest of its members and others. TSA now represents over 700 maritime-registry fishing
vessels, their owners, shrimp processors and associated crews and workers that make up a total
,..........
population of approximately 35,000 full time employed individuals. The interest ofTSA's
members includes the protection and enhancement of the populations of the native shrimp and
~ the habitat of those shrimp. Harvesting of native shrimp stocks by members ofTSA and others
has a significant impact on the State's economy, producing more than $600 million per year in
revenues. In comparison, the production value of Texas' commercial shrimp farms in 1995 was
$33 million. The members ofTSA have an interest in the protection of the native shrimp from
negative impacts of operations of shrimp farms
r
In the past, TSA has taken a number of specific steps to reach its goals, including, but
not limited to:
TSA has been a participant in four Texas shrimp farm TNRCC public hearings, in
1993,1994,1996, and 1997;
2 TSA is a member of a federal panel developing a shrimp virus ecological risk
assessment, which includes an assessment of the risks from Texas shrimp farms;
3. TSA played a key role in developing shrimp farming bills during the 74" and 75"
Texas State Legislature that would have provided needed environmental protection
for Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays; and
4 TSA regularly participates in processes that allow the public to influence state and
federal environmental regulatory policies in Carancahua Bay and other Texas bays
On behalf of its members, EDF and TSA seek to protect the coastal and aquatic
resources of Carancahua Bay. I f issued, the perm it would allow significant degradation of the
water quality, habitat and aquatic species in Carancahua Bay.
EDF arid TSA seek only actions of the Commission within the power of the Commission
to protect the interests of EDF and TSA and their members The participation of individual
members of the EDF and TSA is not required because the members seek only the same results as
EDF and TSA, and no specific relief to the benefit of any individual member.
,--
-Movants allege and stand ready to prove that the discharges of Applicant will be
harmful to the water quality, habitat and aquatic species in Carancahua Bay. -Carancahua Bay
has limited ability to disperse the water and biological pollutants from the extremely large
volumes of highly turbid and low oxygen discharges of lhe Applicant's farm because it is
shallow, warm and poorly circulated. -The Applicant's proposed wastewater discharges to
Carancahua Bay could have negative environmental effects. *For example, exotic shrimp
r-' viruses could be spread to Carancahua Bay, a Slate designated shrimp nursery, and to wild
shrimp populations; high turbidity could kill aquatic vegetation and animals, such as sea grass
beds and oyster reefs; the bay's sportfishing potential could be diminished by high turbidity and
resultant murky water conditions; and low oxygen conditions could eliminate important aquatic
plants and animals from the Carancahua Bay ecosystem
Under both the federal and state law of standing, all Movants have sufficient basis for
standing. In Save Our Communities v. U.S. EPA, 971 F.2d1155 (5'h Cir. 1992) for example, the
Circuit Court specifically recognized that injury to aesthetic, environmental and recreational
interests was sufficient to support standing in a water pollution case. Quoting the U.S. Supreme
Court in U.S. v S.C.R.A.P., 412 U.S. 669, 93 S. Ct. 2405 (1973), the Court also stated that the
injury need not be economic and that the threshold of injury is low for standing. Texas Courts'
require special injury. However, Texas laws, including TNRCC statutes. do no limit the injury
to economic ones. Ecological, scientific, recreational and other interests can be sufficient for
standing in Texas Courts (and thus agency hearings).
/
r-'
Finally TNRCC rules recognize that use of the impacted natural resource is part ofthe
test of an affected person. 30 TAC $55.29 (c) (5).
Furthermore, Movants have special expertise to assist the Commission in evaluating the
ongoing and proposed activities of the Applicant. The Movant's interests are redressable by a
favorable ruling to change the permit to provide more restrictive discharge limitations and
require the Applicant to change its practices associated with the discharges
II. REASONABLENESS
Movants do not seek a hearing to raise issues outside of the jurisdiction of the
Commission. Movants do not seek to raise issues other than those related to water pollution
Movants seek changes in the draft penn it. Movants seek a hearing because of the
deficiencies in the proposed permit and the history or non-compliance of the Applicant,
including the discharge of pollutants without a penn it for approximately eight years
,.-..
~
.---
--.
The hearing requests of Movants sre reasonable under all relevant fJlclor.; set fanh in.3D
TAC 5 55.3\(1)) (I).
1. The application dos not involve a pollution reduction project;
2 Neither the application nor project is mandate by Commission rules;
3. The location of the discharge is Csrancahua Bay, an area that provides economic and
recreational benefits to members of EDF and TSA;
4. Applicant has not asked to substitute an equivalent or more efficient control device;
5 These hearing requests are based on impacts to Movants directly related to water
pollution and to impacts of the operation ofa wastewater facility by Applicant;
6. Movants and the members of EDF and TSA are clearly impacted, as described
above, and those impacts are significant; and
1. 'The Applicant has operated since about 1990 without a permit, despite the
knowledge that one was required. This constitutes a pattern of egregious conduct
that demonstrates a consistent disregard for the regulatory process. The Applicant
has profited from its failure to obtain a permit. It has not had to implement controls
that would have been required. It has not had to do the sampling and reporting that
would have been required
m. COMPETENT EVIDENCE
Movants seek a hearing and the opportunity to present their evidence in support of these
hearing requests. Movants are prepared to present testimony, including expert testimony about
the fact that the discharges of Applicant will adversely affect Carancahua Bay and the interests
of Movants.
IV. PROPER REQUEST
These requests for hearing meet all requirements ofJO TAC 655.21. They are timely
filed with the chief Clerk and are pursuant to rights to hearings authorized by the Texas Water
Code and the Texas Administrative Procedure Act.
V. COMMENTS
As comments, Movants provide this pleading. Movants have added an ..... in front of
each sentence above that Movants submit as a comment as a basis for the hearing requests.
/".
r
In addition, Movants submit the following comments (and additional bases for the
hearing requests).
The permit's proposed limitations established by the TNRCC do not provide
environmental safeguards adequate to protect the coastal water quality and marine
ecosystems of the Carancahua Bay ecosystem.
2. The Harlingen Shrimp Farm permit issued by the Commission in July, 1998 contains
four key protections that should be included in the Applicant's permit I) limitations
on wastewater discharges and pollutant inputs; 2) best management practices; 3)
third-party monitoring; and 4) wastewater toxicity testing
J Movants recommend that mass-based discharge limitations (pounds of
pollutant/day) should be included in the permit, in addition to the draft permit's
proposed concentration-based limits (milligrams of pollutant/liter of water), for
carbonaceous biochemical oxygen demand (CBODS), ammonia-nitrogen (NH3-N),
and total suspended solids (TSS). The use of mass-based limits encourages shrimp
farmers to reduce their discharges while concentration-based limits help to avoid
excessive concentrations of pollutants in the mixing zone where the effluent is
diluted by receiving waters Together these limitation will help the industry
minimize its risk for contributing to coastal water quality degradation problems and
introducing biological pollutants such as exotic shrimp species and shrimp diseases.
4. The draft permit allows the Applicant to discharge more water - a daily average and
maximum of2.5 and 7.S million gallons per day (MOD), respectively - than its
operations appear to require. Movants recommend that the discharge limitation
more accurately represent the Applicant's operations. For example, the permit
limitations should reflect the seasonal nature of the discharge- maximum August
through November.
5. TNRCC proposes to limit inorganic suspended solids (lSS) instead of total
suspended solids (T5S), as the agency has required on past shrimp farm permits
Movants recommend retaining the use ofTSS in order to maintain a measure of
phytoplankton which is not included in a measure of 15S. Shrimp farmers cultivate
moderate to dense phytoplankton blooms in ponds which, when discharged in large
volumes, can degrade water quality by creating turbid and low oxygen conditions.
The Environmental Protection Agency has informed TNRCC, with regards to federal
------
permits for SI. Martin's and Harlingen shrimp farms, that "due to lack of data to
draw a correlation between TSS and lSS, the Agency agrees not to replace TSS with
lSS".
6. Movants recommend that toxicity testing be an enforceable condition of the permit
to detect the presence of hannful chemicals, toxic bacteria, and other pollutants that
are not measured in the standard discharge limitations. This testing should be
conducted at least once per harvest
7. Movants recommend that TNRCC allow third-party monitoring of the farm's
operations.
8 Movants recommend that TNRCC require the use ofbeSl management practices
(BMPs) as an enforceable condition of the penn it in order to prevent or minimize the
generation of pollutants, their release, and potential release from the farm to the
Slate's waters. BMPs for the Applicant's shrimp fann should include the following
requirements:
r
Vegetate or otherwise stabilize earthen levees and dikes to reduce TSS and
ISS resulting from erosion.
. Consider especially sensitive habitats and animals to be affected. Effluent
discharges should not negatively impact endangered species habitat, other
important habitats, or other economic or recreational uses.
. Minimize routine water exchange by maintaining high pond water quality and
using supplemental aeration as needed. The daily maximum water exchange
rate between Carancahua Bay and the fann should not exceed 5% of the
fann's total volume
. Use settling ponds to cleanse wastewater before it is discharged
. Minimize use of water amendments. For example, reduce fertilizer use and
do not use lime unless fallow pond soils are acidic There should be no
wastewater discharge for at least 30 days after pond water is fertilized
. Use a feed that gives optimum growth and feed conversion at the lowest
possible protein level, has a high sinking rate, and has high water stability.
. Use feeding trays instead of broadcast feeders to manage and adjust feed
inputs
~.
, "!"
r--
Distribute the day's ration in multiple feedings a few hours apart to improve
feed conversion and growth, and reduce accumulation of uneaten feed
. Cease feeding at least three days before harvest.
. Incorporate use of wetlands, oyster ponds, and/or fish ponds to clean or
eliminate effluent water, where appropriate
Do not remove pond sludge unless necessary. Dispose of sludge on high
ground.
Initiate and maintain biosecurity measures such as fencing and limitations of
vehicular and personnel traffic to reduce the risk of disease outbreaks and
transrn ission to coastal waters
Movants request timely and full response to its comments
VI. CONCLUSIONS
WHEREFORE, Premises Considering, Movants request a hearing on the application and
that the proposed penn it be denied or revised to protect the water quality, habitat, and aquatic
life ofCarancahua Bay. Movants also seek a full and detailed response to each of the comments
r
Respectfully submitled,
[, .J'Y-
-';YV"'--,-"L~ .12..
Melinda E. Taylor
SBN 19714030
Senior Atlorney
Environmental Defense Fund
44 East Avenue, Suite 304
Austin, Texas 7870]
(512)478.5161
..-
,': '.'. (i ~ (;:" .
;"".l'~f .. ,U'.'i' :'e'
,',,-:'_<:.:'J
~ ~ 'i I' . J C',- '.' ~ ':',
@)
CCA TX
NEWS
6..,: i '} POF",'(,,: Lri\'c. ':uik : IY,I H~~\\,r.or", l'c-X,t5 )'ij)~':+
\"",'.'\v.c,~atc'xa;;, nrg
January ~_ lOrn
CO!\L\CT: Pal ,\lumlv f:OO.1>26.4122
EXECUTIVE ALERT
Cllns~rrati(lnists Question Proposed Shrimp farm
H\lU~tOll. '1'.X -- Lo;,;al \..':_H1scr\'ati~~ilists mId angJ...'fs an; LlUl.,;'sti(Hling a pl.2nnit l(H' a pfi..)po:~~d
shrimp tanl1 in th: 1>011 :\110 ale-a. This (\.:ustaJ fJi..;ility could rd~~a~;l; hannfltl di~..JLlrg..::, LT,=ated during
the :-;hrimp 1~trll~ing prol2ess_ inhl the deh.:atc mars!l of nearby Carancalma Uay
If Jppnlved, the permit would allow 4.000.00010 as much a:- 8.000,000 gallons or diluent
discharge b.:: relenstd dn1i~ irom the shrimp frrnl_ into the lragik adjac:=nt nnrsh. Carancahua Hay was
d';:~lgtlah.:d a nurscT:-' ar(,;<l ::md currcntly b~fh:tits II-om a han on <,:;'JItuncr..:iat shrirnping. It is a -.::rul:ial
pan ofth~ esttlar~' syst~m that nourishc:'s the gh~ah:'r Port 0' Connor arEd and ~l!rretltly sustaLf1S a rich
hahitat ofli\'c o:,'skr r~ds.
"Th~ dl1u~m \.hschdrg~ hum thi:- ta('i1ity could equal that of a city~" said h~n l'dorris, chairman
of the C<Jrani-;ahna Hay Prote<.:tion Association, "Th~ impact on \oc::\l crabs. shrimp, u~"s1er5 and linfisl1
t..:culd be Ycr~' d,,~trimental. Th\...-'n.' is :.lis\.) a scriow; erosion probkm in th~ area of the propos~d HlnTI that
could re-lease nOlH1ati\'~ shrimp and any a~~5ocia10d viruses into nati\'e populations of shrimp during
th~ 111gh tides oflfopii..'al ~~t0nl1 sy~1ems. This all could b~ a rea! problem."
Sllrimp farms can pr,)du.;~; a helldit for ....'oastal ba:v's and ~stuaries by 'JfTscuing the impact of
c~)mmerCi31 shrimping practice~; \.,,'hile 8.111 maintain)l1g a skady tlO\\/ of ~~afood, But unfoJ1utl3tcly.
th;';S2 ttlcililie~ ar.;: ot::;:n tlljn~d jn signiJi<.'ant ut.:gati\'e ~nvironm.;;:ntal impad due 10 the improper
disposal of\yastewater produced in the shrimp t~lrming process and shrirnp \'iruses that can mi~ct
nativ~ shrimp slocks. Some ~hnmp t~ll'HlS aiong th,e south Texas coast have produced signiticant
probkms in ~.....\'era] k..:y ,;;,stuar:,-- m~a;.; ilnd hav~ ';"ome undc'f scrutin)' b~/ Cvastal Conseryation
,\ssixiation T~xas. T~xas Parks and \Vildlif~ D.:-partment and Texas Commission (~!1 Environmental
(Jualit\: TCL<)) :<1\iciab
TCEQ lia, schedulc'd a public hearing Ie)/" Janllarv 14. 20Ci3 al 7 P~[ a\ lhe Days Inn in p()r1
Lava,,:a to answer lll1..:'stions ~Uld r~cei\'e pub!i;; input regarding the decision mnking proces..s for lhis
p;:nnit. \\-'ith the po:"sibk enviromDL'lltaJ impact of this proposed shrimp nlrm~ it is vital that
":lHls~n'ati(injs1" keep a watdlnil e)'e on the permining process. CCA Texas representatives \\/ill give
t~~t~mon~ allhc h~aling.
'"'*[ND"'"*
~.)v
V
;;
."
p:46-lJ.. I
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r We. the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
r
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge pennit no, 04001.
./1) "J~0.,JL.v- <;-4-CL .-2) {J./AJ-~./ #. ?~ J J)....... ..s o1Q;l.,
Signature Dale Slgnatu Date
,J........e.S p ,-M,....s"..... VI.r~c. 12 JOhn ,ivrl
Prinled Name Printed
\'S}()\t. 1.4,~(. C"tt.J<. D""", )5"10/,, R'os"-'" ('10 I-!/u<jt:'?_ tJ,.
Mailing Address Mailing Address
J!t.".;h,.,'B'\(Q~ .101,,9 No,.- -; "to /) TY '"J'l a",'1
City, State, ilP City, State, ZIP
.lafffi1/1//hll'~~Y'V7-<101 6/'1IDti)~A -r. ~
SIgnature, Date SignatureV
J..\~ ~. J~A.) Cllll~ {>. I'\e~~
Pnnted Name Printed N e
0~r7r0 ~-'l:,vJ'~i C6. 41- CP}..J~,e...
Mailing Address Mailing Address
(k\1(N"n, IL- 1..tiG1P07 1t.v 11-.J,O.$\
Coty. State, ZIP City, State, ZIP
V5.)~~ ~-r-~)-'6l ~~Q",..::> 5/..1/02..
~'~ure Date Signature Dale -
,)OF f/7~q N 11-11- 's" 'JJ <A:r.t-S
Printed Name Printed Name
{I; <;,,3 ~-LI-,# '-1/7[1.,.;..;"1"11' 7)0{ JC17 A.J
Mailing Address Mailing Address
~ N "?/V ~~ POLT L".///fCA, 7v
CIty, State. ZIP City, Stale, ZIP
S-4-l> 1..
Date
~
~)v
~ 2-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
,... We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1. to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 10 add each of the Undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
r
""&4/""- /'",'1':.6'" 'X~~ 4"f!:!j"
G./nv?/h )((jOp L....s/~ T kDoo
Printed Name Printed Na f
/}(Y/ ,,,'In..niVil/l-;: /}ol./ ,<;U7"1fVJ'/E
Mailing Address Mailing Address
.[:-(//&,1 ty 779~7 FdNA- Tl 7775/
City, Slate, ZIP City, Slale, ZIP
,-;, ~-::::v- ~.,.~ (a...LL-.!).<. O--~'''--
Signature Date Signature Date
/2/.. oJ...16//(-f~<--- (1rne/,......Normo.n"_ tlhr'l.erl
Pnnted Name Printed Name
//9 M.,. ~/f -;r. L,. ~ .,,,. 4.< s. PD Ro'J/ 8~
Mailing Address Mailing Address
-:;;...-J- L.G.v<c<.., r;.. 77'i ?'J
City. State, ZIP
/J .x .5-O.l.
"5) c:Yd1n.. j::,".///~~
~ature ~e- .
-k'RlHl.....J eUI{>LL 'f(ttI,6H. r
Printed Name
,--..
1~7 1tla.('sA...C(
.ling Addfess
a.
City, late, Zl
~Y:-J~ S-S-~
Signature Date
R:r:sten Norrt..QMI_ B~r::.~"
Printed Name
:::JDhll><?"r\AtJc: Po 80ll '?{g9
Mailing Address
1 ~ta~*,1i '71<101
2)J
";OA-~F:>. ;3
"
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r- 'II/e, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
';astaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
r-
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
~:~U S~;-o ~
Can/fill l8""klt:l.
Printed Name
;l{g 7/ M,"rJlu in
Mailing Address
~~S~nl(X. 77057
City, Slate, ZIP . (
1~4<< ~~ 5~5~2-
gna ure Date
Su oS a,n W~ fe.rs
Printed Name
Rf. I, BtJX .J7 g
Mailing Address
y.;h~rton . 7BKrl5 71,,"
J~
3) ,"""--2..4)
Signature Dale
-g(""~+- ~""W-
Printed Name
Date
J..It>""l( ~ r., I, ~ L.......
Mailing Address
Hol(..~'" IX. 7705'7
City, State, ZIP
'-.J
City, Slate. ZIP
\
Printed Name
Date
5) ,
Signature...
//
Prlnle<l Name /'
1""-
Maili~7ess ~
City, State, ZIP
Date
6)
Signature
City, Slale, ZIP
..
Page L~.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
,-
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by lener to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
V'1>,i ~
Signature Date gnature ,
1<!;f;f,fNI AlDof'l:JJ'I _1<'0 ("~" \I~o/I./ q~
Prmted Name Printed Namll ~
:Ffn J1-.A-Jti" G...U"\ e.O . (361 ( 2 ~ I
Mailing Address Mailing Address
NlP\t/1l it 773' (, 2RJ.c.l' L c'l. T,r 774'.>-
City. Slate, Zl City, Stalll, lIP
~ i~6 1JtfWlJ.o~~-HOl- ,-tA)al\\l'~.) ~M~--'l-t>"L-
Srgnal Dale Signawlll Date
~~;"'rl(f MncnJOV1 \~V,vv\1t \:>d\e+\
nnled N6me ~
3'9~ 7 WI"'."\-eVCj ree 1'1 3 b J 'j' 1/1)1.,,.. ~ ~(\\u-e.
MaHmg Address Mailing Ad~
\-\u.W\bt~ \\"x 77356 Hu.....tR t/ 77.3'76
City, Stale, ZIP City, Slale, tip
C--1"'>>.-
Dale
4402-
S--09~ 02
Dale
.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
./
P.4c'::rFL-
t3
r- We. the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
r
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning p'ropQ. d discharge pannit no. 04001.
v,; " 5.".0'<~., 4l: 0. \ S -1-D.2.
Signatu Dale ignature -0- Date
R.J. /2,S't.~y ~~~...~~ If;.../fo/
Printed Name Printed Name
/('pc, ~~r~r: I~, -r..blll..t s+-
Mailing Address Mal 'nj Address
~4.~ a"," h. 7'4G.5 -P4- It'.I'IS -1 x. ?,~.~
City, Stale. ZIP City. Stale, ZIP'
v{~""'~#l/ -~/#~~4L'~A-tJ,~~ /Jta V'- ;$""-1/>
SlQnalUre Date S ature Date
i~ ~~47"
L7PY #~;H# 1':3.YJi.n",f- ~1'
Mailing A dress Mailing Addreu
-(~ ,~A/ 7>~ 7/'J97 .
I... City,
, I / 'fi-/u u?-
~ ~ X$"/~t!u1 ~
~nat. ... Date
f:r"stPH &i<€&lJ~~K
Printed Name
ff"
02--
7'14-a~'r~~
Printed Name
M({,,1l~4'
:;:'-=-/L) --t:'~ '7-
f
rinted Name
'? eft -r eO fA. r ~ r:
Ma;9 Address
h l:I~m,j Tt
JJi.t:i;;Sr (T>t' 17 'fi, S--
Mailing Address
~ f-..t:O..r Tx I- 7 (6r
City. State. ZIP I I
V
p~&~
1'-1-
------
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk ofTNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saltas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing conceming the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association; ")
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
~~uJ~(jn^"/~ 2)' I!-/; ()~/~d~ !i-to-f);;).
~alure ~ Date ~ure Date
. 5-/O-0l tf,h, Add vnUI1
Prinled Name
Mi,T!~ A~h~ r^ k /J (I ~ 'J-
'l'llflA' ~1r.\:/tJ~ K 17Y(;~
City, State, ZIP
, ;.-...(~~ f!'/',
Dale Signature
JuAt'./J#I!$I ZJ"...;) / jyt!'v'
G <>,c. I S- t:"" Printed Name
. . ? Z /P TrDd- S..,L
Mailing Address ........ 77'" (!,.- Mailing Address
. 1":!..~~e;>J9~ ~ tj)
rl!l./a",,'.o.~ ~ I K 771-r,-r"
'City, Slate, ZIP
04~ 1- rtloJt
~dd'ess
~ \oc.\O~ 1\t
City, Stale, ZIP
3)
Signature
!le-j;e,/GrnI
Printed Name f? o.
City, Stale, ZIP
\.~
~.-IO.
Date
ignalure
~ic! aJ..
P"nted Name J
JJ tl Sot sf,
Mailing Addrass
.tJ~
City, Stale, Z P
~ 1l( ~ 1
v' Pfi-Gr-112....
I~
~
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
,
r We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaD, ma
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We besfch the
Executive Director:
r
1 to granllhe request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge ~ ,rmit no.
04001, which was made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from I< m Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharg, permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2,2002, frc 1 Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association; ')
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mallingst
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
j -f ~ J gk"/ '~. "" L tC
1~~ _' .,~}. . :tt'~" . '~\I:? 71\.\)2...
gig .atu 0 te Signa ure Date
Ii"~'~ /3~/1~/.., . ~ll"-\"(. ~r~
~ ~ ~~N~
R-I-3 ~ IrJ~,- 8 R~ J.. Y>>~ m
Mailing Ad!'iress Mailing Address
1=7 f'd.....A>~# i7~7... J\ t,..-.. 1'f.. "'\\'\~I
I~~~ ~ ./ City,State,ZIP'
3)41L(~rS:'~ t-z- 4) ~4r"-rj t"){L ;j"-.Hn--
ignalure at Signature Date
(H.6L- ~Sd-1J &....L ~~ O/JoP
Pnnt~ Name Printed Name
?c{IS'Fo...,/'p,ei:-,tJ 7-1/) ;Co.-./~
M~lllng Address Mailing Address
..)husro;J 1Y- -770 7Y tf/)vSf).J ,7;. , 17D71_
City,.State, ZIP r City. State, ZIP' .~.
~\,nature6)~g~ ;(~~yto!./
~I ~-tN/ VoJ:"k'
Pritte! Name
'2?? 7l,.v T .5 r
Mailing Address .
rf.lJvrc,.t, ~ T~ '77f.-jt.S
City, Slate, ZIP .
Printed Name
,
.. 3) i)- dr./~
.'. Mailing Address
1(.1',( NO Tr nJ'tS-
City, State, ZIP
"
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
VP.A-b-~
1.b
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaD. 1n3
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We best ,ch the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge ~ ,rmil no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from ~ '" Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharg< permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2,2002, fre1 Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association; ")
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below lo the TNRCC mailing .st
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
I ,f.f,b
~~r1/i!,~ ..b';-l"~?- 2) ~~
Si9. alure Date $igna ure
~~~at: &-/~ "J.I",-=_ ~f~~ LJirlf
Pc V1IIJ./JrI'l /:;J:;lq' J?,~M<-
Mailing Adgress Mailing Address
_Et eAmA>/ ~ 7'Z414~ '.' P5L. d"~d c::;: "'7?/;'3'7
City, Stale, IIp City, Stale, IP /
.~,., . .h.LJ ' , /-
3) rrh WT/t-.--~ ,,_IV'-PV' ;-:,0.- v""'"
Signature Date ate
J:?rr;,(lJJ VUhd1<y
~ ed Name e
/CYaLf [))nna Oilvt .;lS.;lf Vi {J e. (l ;rJ~
Mailing Address Mailing Address ~ .
.elfurnfV{7?\"i7\f3l j{g.iM tA
Citv1ate, ZIP City, S~tr/. tiP
5/I~fflCC~<<lk5/;~/a,26>' V
$Ig~lure Dale Signature ./ /
ffJJr~ /ph kY"7 ._ ~:rT
_ Printed a Printed Name
, l''f95 kDllI(.~~)~ 4st}{'t- ~
~~"J~;b~ TX 77'111t MZ'2:: 7V A (
City, State, ZIP I City, Stale, ZIP I, r 77 LJ 21
.s-:/o "02-
Date
h.
. '.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
Page II
.
We. the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. La Donne
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2.2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mall/ng list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
~ t-Wh4 )C;;~htr/!/1g~~ "~""~t1t. 5/IRlfJ~
Signature Date Signatu Date I '
-/~l.JrtJ~ SIMNJQrI..++.. Kpifh l~"Ia.:f+e~
Printed Name Printed Name
~~dr!1f.el1nlln. {1.n.sfl.r,. ':i~~ib1r..IIA" (1ru,I-Ln.
E I C&.rt~. Ti 7747tf 5U-4:tr/~. TJ( 771:71'
City, Slale. ZIP <<gttr/tu,ct City, Wte, ZIP
Date
4)
Signature
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. State. ZIP
Date
6)
Signature
Dale
Prinle<l Name
Mailing Address
City. Stale, ZIP
.
VPIUrf!;
/9
PETITION
Regarding Proposed THRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
;--.
We, the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed disCharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge pennit no. 04001.
LJt.uJ-1'.Jb -dJ~.-... -{ ~ C~ .s--/I'-o-
Sifature ale Signature Cate
.}w--mo""'r~ .sf..~< CkcJ-rc..--
Printed Name Printed Name
IIlq c.,1lU)}Oi....... IJ/"o 7 t..nl/ r.h./ j)"","/ /.vt.
Mailing Address Mailing Address
Poa-; l A\lAC.A '"1'"'1t 77q~, Cey",j.J'. r~ ;);, r j.J
C' . Stale. ZIP C' ,Stala, ZIP
r-
~
S lure al
i~~ ~.\\\Up 2:" I v.~6.€fl
Pri led Name
I\+') C' ,Q ?fl7 ~
Mailing Addras
t>ou-It,-~ ~ '71f9'H
City, Stale, ZIP
/) ~'(\').~E?~.D_' ~ I
____~ -JIJ():l.
Signature ate
c:;:>,AR~j-j p~ N'31\Be}.)e
Printed Name
lI<.lq C.-;:>. :!o7. p.
Mailing Address
,.-
P<?{<\ I.J=\-lIk~, TX ??9'l'f
City. Stale, ZIP
~ ~~~ !;:"((-o;>
Signature Date
ib6 ~ yo '"j-- 7Q: rf '" y
Prinled Name
n S"OQ 11-1' sa S- <-,
... ~
Mailing Addl'8H
~"..t:I". n
City, J iI
A-1S'~
lP-' fOr '('
v'i8' KJll
r-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
/
Page I c;
~
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection ASSOciation;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
r
~)L#t_~
Grlgnature ./
;}1lJr1t,. /1. LA;',
Printed Name
2VC/17I1'4uJ/JOD
Mailing Address
5~ A""",,,,,,, 7k 78:U"'-f
City, State, ZIP
/lJ".", /r,l.,l
Date
2)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. State, ZIP
Date
4)
Signature
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Stale, ZIP
f{f-t;~ J8-
___ PETITION
~roposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
.
We. the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castaiiuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Cieri( dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing conceming the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, Which was made by fetter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
ro~ml"" "'....... """"..."",,, ",001.. . /.
~. ~/h 01. r;1/ d:' ~--___ 41/:tt
Signature Date ' Signature ' Date
f\\.c.""tit.- J . ~ft>l,:. ~~ 4~\diR.OJIjc:>
Printed Name Printed Name
~o PM 518 'lt2c>~1 Uilc..( (P~fK.s.\f\.c l~1
Mailing Address MaiUng Address
K.""Jtll.<.J",",)). 11' 77:5fN ~.J \~ GI'T:::a 7l:i.]3
City, State. ZIP c." Slate ZIP
vi' .~, ,
3) ~rr~O/-,e~ { ~~-Jf-o~
Signature Date Signature Date
~~y~1:di; oVI/-6A.
IJ 19 (I..... Rjl. ~o7 A/
Mailing Address
r-
.,..
S-l -07...
Oate
~
XN' A- {;}.. /..'-O~
Printed Name
13c-lIQ5 a. RtJ ~'7 iV
~ing~ r1
~ I --r:;. 7'79
City, Slate. ZIP .
c
V
6) 1>1......'I.;t?.~ :;:'19-t>2...
Signatureo Dala
{l1A-t't L Ih ~
Printed Name
3~ wl4'te QVIL...
Mailing Address
M L:..t"Q......., T~. '7 '7 97 '1
City, Stete, ZIP
.
,/ Page.2:..l
r--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concernil'lg the propo$ed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of CarancahuB Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing conceming the proposed discharge permi\
no. 04001, which was made by feller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04 01.
-'Jri-og2.
Dale
GA~) L. 0&vrs
Prin\llld me
Cf'6 /Y'f!~9(IJO Li Pi ~I
Maifing Addiil.
ft I"lT 4\ VM A .......i;.; T/'f77
City. Slate, ZIP
/"'"'
.; ~ It~
.'~/% . . -
1}. '/' -;; .!J:~/7~
Stgl1&luce 08\e
m J./. re IS
"rinted Name
//7..<1 Cf.:.3C7/
Mailing Address
tf}r../ MI./R.-t'~ 7?' .7:FJ 79
City, State. ZIP /
I. 'j J I' I I ' ;,/
V 3) /,1 I' l ,? ': ,. . J ( 1'1
, Signature ' 0aIit,
,.
<./ ~n n ~ r:?--.
4) C:;"'k~ ~. ~ - ~ Ii' 'l~ --c>~
Signature Dale
kdw.+...J t. Woe d
Printed NlIIl1e
/1'/ f>~j7"(5.J j,v
Mailing Address MaiHng Adcl....
. ,__ >>'rTI.~ M ~~~
City. Stale, ZIP City, State, ZIP
~~ C~~>I.J-~~l" .t"e~? ';;;:'
,.-~ X; ~S t; \=' <!)tt ~:11~ l': H I)L;'j;~ ,( 7'-" '-I. ~.
Printed Name Prtnted Name
., 5.5 C. f~ ":,f)-{ l-\ ?,., 'J- ., i c - /(
Mailing Addreu M~;~~" . " I
?'Rl Al:ro 'li'11.::J /r/~ 7 /'.1<..)C
City. Stale. ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
. ILIJi -;
Prin\llld Name
., "'":.'
.. ~ #"; .
'7
.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
I p;rbt1- }3::-
r-
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2,2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
,....
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
/
~~~~ /In...,,.).;J,)4~ 2)
ignat ~ tUfa Date Signature Date
fI<,'HU.iWloU-
SAIII1 CflflL60N
Printed Name Printed Name
"2 05 {3f}f,} f3u.fl 'f
Mailing Address Mailing Address
\kc;Jv(l.p. ,T~~ 77'iV<J.
City, Stale, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
4)
Signalure
Dale
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate. ZIP
Oale
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
~age 2-3
.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We. the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Ca5tanuela. to deliver our message to ExecutiVe Director Jeffrey A. SallaS. We beseech the
Executive Director:
,. \0 granllhe reque.t for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed "..rlng concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concern. ropOsed discharge permit n 001
j /' I
.. I
~(
f'ri f . ame Prinled N e
J/).r flAiJqpj 8r.t~,r cf~'~' JJ:' It>\IWr'''- ~ t~
Mailing,AIldress fr.{fI f.:l, Mailing Address T"?'i"2-, LA-VJk.A- TX
~~ '(!,I~X, 7?/{stf T{ _J>OM M'"t"o ~797Q
'1)<. Sta City. State. ZIP I
. /. / 'Y61t1~1lM-A \')t
~) '7f~ ~~..b-U/ ';:d~""'2..")
Signature ' . Date Slgnatu.... Oale
AI/tIV'c!.lf 4.5p~"v ~ bJJAZZj./
Pnntlld Name I' . N
/7,#.r E. 7'j',.je.6ad #""/.5 U~ ~
MalllOg Add,l!$S Mailing Add,...
ltc-/~~/;? "7')(,771"/ P..J- t:l.RZi'J ~ 77Q7
City. Slate. ZIP City, State. ZIP I r '1
5) 6)
Signature Date Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City. Stale. ZIP City. State. ZIP
.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r-" We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuera, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
V pft&pJ. 3..f--
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by lelter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
cOflceming proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
c'~~D. ~~ "r;;/z.-3 /0 1- l~Q7lA.J..- b. Avv'litJ r;1:-3 10 "-
Signature Dale Signature 0 e l
6E:R.AL O:AJf: '5, GAP-f{c rr L /J).
Printed Name Printed Name
r-
r, () . P.,O)( ~O
Mailing Address
DMJE:... V ItAfh ,-~X A:5 11~J~.
City, State, ZIP ,
Q.D. ~D)(.ll-oO
Mailing Address
DME:. vMb I~K A5 11c{-~:J-
City, State, ZIP I
3)
4)
Signature
Date
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
City, State, ZIP
5)
Slg!\at!ire
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
r-.
City, State, ZIP
City. State, ZIP
.'
-
'--' .'
1/4- ~I;i:.. v "- :?
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castanuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permil
no. 04001, which was made by fetter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no, 04001.
v 4
1);J j[ ~
S.gnature \
S'.,/.OZ-
Date
1...:/ E ,~~i) r.,€.La...
Printed Neme
J 2..-. ~f J/ C.II-' n flv en t~J( RIND
Mailing Addre$S .
Wbv<7bAJ 7K~PS 77{J9(
City, State, zip
Date
Date
~~~~~,556L
Signature Date
;1I.c/t'A4 IJ I//l<k~ ,~^-I
Printed Name
~i) I J)j4~ tk.
Mailing Address
ad)lf~ jJ~( ,'" 73G.L5
City. State, ZIP
4)
Date
Signature
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. Stale, ZIP
.;: z6
PA-E...r;
..
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
. )-2--
r--
\
?
~
/'7..
('
K~
.
r
r-
,r-
/PA-&~ "2-7
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
/ I.lJlo-z.-,/ .I --1# H:
~/\ . 2) ~R7/M7-O-< 'l.///~~
Date 'Signature _. Date
E;/5!'O 0//Ev'fi/L;'1
Printed Name
/
1) I
Si atu
..,].fle.. (~tl~.l)a.i'/1
Printed Name -
~\) (v\..v~.....~l\ l...rtrw<;D,J 87 ,~/I 57:-
Mailing Address Mailing Add
~Jr-+- Ll><vC<CA- .\^ 71'1(79) ~,T~t/Ik'#} 7:i 77979
ity. State, ZIP , City, Slate, ZIP
I~) ~(J'!i, )JNJI'f)~ ~f!Jlov ~~~ '7\ lC01vd-
. Signal re ' Date ~. ture ~ \ \ Date I
~fin "2;/tCA;' ~o'\.. ~ y.\\\.....\l
Printed N me Printed Name
1411 M6t'~/{ JfJ1vt:tDn J/vt AL '0""\ \,,,~...,, t\......
Mali,"g Address Mailing Address
fJt)/f Ih.VUL4., Tf:. 77f19 t. \ c... "'......... ~ C) '"\ -#. \. ""'\ '\ "\ """\
City, SllIIe, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
/5>- (j/~~ .J)lfol' J(~'~';~J;j~k6{19/60
.~ __ Date v6~e Da~
a~~~:; ~~d~7 poMl!i!!-l Ml \~ {(
7~():LCtr;td.<<(~cl 'D(\gt~ 17_ q
Mailing AdjdS ~ ~j dress
~~z~ Jl1; 1. ~~I~ TK ~l1q51
.
.
P.4-G-~ z.. {?
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director;
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
'-
-
s ~:;X /.. no" hi fpI. ~J i)
Mailing Address I
t'a...-\- In. I/O n', T X -]")9) '7
City, State, ZIP
~~u~t/ 4" ~~cial:4
/f?/ ;n~>:..f:,~
15rinted Name
57 Ituf-h" ~4.A'~~ n/
Mailing Address .
,.--
e- ./.IM4~it I5r '175"7 7
City, Slale, 1 .
~M_d~
' Signatu're
Ith./I..o'; ~A.A.J
, Printed Name
r-:- L
~.J- /d AI A. T:##,
Mailing Address
'1?..7 f.."j///t'A 7Y 7?~ 7 '7
City, Slale. ZIP 1
->-:1-1-,,"'2.
Date
{~aA% yyY~-.21-{)2
Signature Dale
..5irI ; ~ \"1 ffiAl~~t 1#'"\
Printed Name .
~ Wh\*'t- rY}AP.\ \(\ '0e.
Mailing Address
.P4' L-Av~ 1Y-.r-'f '7 'L1 q
City, Stale, ZIP
~A"~ I &-c..,... 5'-,;2/-" .:z-
ignalure Oate
~AAl", fir) RtJ
Printed Name
//(/1 d
I~:l. r" Al A
'Mailing Address
/!..{){ Lllvf/-".A Tx
~:t,'
Sig re
yJ. .::r, S-ONNI/"!
Prinled Name
?'1C?'1 f
.,--2/-l...
Dale
/,j-2"} C"z 3/~
Mailing Address
~4r b v";1o~, T:Y "77j'.?~
City, Stale. ZIP ,
~-
r'PA-&tj. 2'7
;
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sallas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the reque$t for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
V;).)j11;- -r S~.' 4,)//"'2) fraA?tLJ ii Jj/JVJh~ 5-,J/- dL
SIgn ure Date Slllnalure Date
OAM......:.c: &~.vNIC.,... InhR..-rJ.l.JJ b. )-FmJ..t:y
Prinled Name 'Prlnted Name
;'-29 c,.~ iYn cJ 7/. ulltd:t.-YlY.:utt./!/dOv
Mailing Address Mailing Address
/;~""'/MU". n :779>9 Pf ~jl;NiA IX 77979
CIty, Stale, ZIP Cily, Sta e, ZIP
3) v'S~.~.A-..S"J~D&-~~a:VV)}n"'A) -S-oU~-():J..
Signature "'-bate gnature Date
SU~H. ff,~Je.'U"" Pet t- t/.'/OQ t::"I
Ponied Name Z.Dt~~....w..,.J Printed Name ,
&U...---. ~I~ ~ .:27tltJ 1Iu/ld/n ~
Mailing Address Mailing Address
E./&rn P<:J. Ii 7 7</37
City. Slate. ZIP ( ,
.-', -P~ ~~~/~~3-~-f)~
Date 'gnalure
t>M~ILf:'-~ !.,8A1tJ!!y
Printed Name
.t..", :;.., /?z 0t'h)/XOAJ (J ~ ~$$/:VJ bk.
Melling Address
J"')( 7~YI,7-:. F3d.AtrrDJJd.7;., ?74.?9-6?6y
City, Stat... ZIP <
. IH~- wc/i>\lt.4ltJt),( ,TJ< 77'lS(
City, Stale, ZIP
,
..,.
JJ.'/s,oN'
,r-
2"9<>.a -;4..,Tt:-h,...,s
Mailing Address
~/ Cla"W2,o.
City, State, ZIP .
"
P#b-a SO
,
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r-
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing 118t
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
,j
1)~-B~u.. t'e S:AS:02..
Signature Date
ROSIN /3AU~,eLc.
Printed Name
,r--.
./2,_ 40K 70 'if
Mailing Address
?4#~O"'~ "lX. 77J162-
City. State, ZIP _ ._h
JJcrIi : ~y ,,*-4 p"-'__.
<-~.1' lU/ 'i ~JlJ.t).
,gnature Date
III t6l!y t.ft...2-Jle 11t'r
Printed Name
24'll ~ t4.4 -fey\(., (t( Or:
Mailing Address
~/;r~n_ 11~5q
City, State, P ,
,.-
l{, ~lt{'I.'\... 1.)').1.) ~
Signature Date
. i
~ '\., ) \ i i Gl, ~"\ I[ C I Ie ,,-
Printed Name
2~(i l ~ 0..-HC'~':',CJl 0, .
MaWng Address
~i'i/'.."I~ ~ ., I 2>?'1
City,'Slate, P
"
2)
Sig ure Date
..Jen(\ tf~r ((.tI (J..- I
Printed Name
,JJ~/'f tnU5-'-:J ~INI )
Mailing Address
mnUklll, ~ 9t~l-~j
City, Stale, ZIP .
/o~
. h,....
4).~I\...~\..(...L L.J& \.(A_~~...:.t, -u ::L
0fr, 1'\1'\; 11 . -fS...t.u..erlt>
Printed Name
(t~ ;)C(Ul.n:.-:h. DA , J-:)4:,.
Mailing Address ~
(-'Cu''tldt ,T~ -;l:.Y-i fo2-
City, Slate, ZIP
. .
~gAddress
16~/, 71=rfj:J5
City, Slate, ZIP "
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
:z 1
i/PA6.-I~ ~
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing conceming the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC rnalllng list
concerning proposed diSCharge permit no. 04001.
~~~~
Si ature
~1f1J~-4c.tN L ({
Printed Name
V
,t)' / >~~
natu~.
I.: ,.-::> I
..)v'\I'" t:>.....,ev' ~
Printed l1ame
f> >: .~c,y. //L~V
Mailing Address
"
l\"..~,<,-,\c \-1.. 1)'ICjb;:J..
City, Stale, ZIP
~<~~JPG. ~
Date
~~~"
Dale
'I ~z.o c-l.;z. %
Mailing Address
~~O tot:
City, State, ZIP
.)~. n::::;;> - ?,,.-_Vy-'
3) 'tUI<+-'. T"'H?"~ {l-' 4)
gnature Date Signature
11Iar(!.(J ~ h. Ba"....., IG.-
Printed Name
q~J.l. ~a Ol".
Mailing Address
rYQ~W)(t~, LlG 77~s4
City, Slate, ZIP
71'U2
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
5) 6)
Signalure Dale Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
r-- Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP City. Slate, ZIP
r /J-b,- 17:- .> 2-
--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, frorn Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was rnade by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
r
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
) con~e.rning 7~0 / osed diScharge~permit ~~o. 0400~1' ~
1)___~ ~.. ~ rr-r.:2 . $-).....,.(lJ-
s~. . !)<<lure' Dale ig turD . Date
~!rse. r~~ All ,bl J4-d~ 0'"
pnn ed Name . Printed Name
l(Jr7!f~o/fLkI>.. /';7'/7'-/ ,Li.",..~,..k/ b~
M~il~ '" dre s Mailing Address ./
~~T/J1\/ (\"7V-77J93 ~~~L- I 7 7d'i)
City, Stale, ZIP I Y j'f '40 rfttr. City, State, ZIP //
3CD~4,1 r5 A ott1~~ ~/--4'4'.L
Signature Date .........Signature -
PrinlefName / GlI'l pf.,~t~me~ 1#&V'-(
~ tt-\ \JJ.Mitt f},~ /;;1.a,~O .(~ /L-
Mailing Address Mailing AddAlSS
\::)~,~ 1 bJg ~~.d~ ~ 77Ph~
City, State, ZIP .-' City, State, ZIP
5- ~ 7C/':l
Date
5) 6}
Signature Date Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
~ Mailing Address Mai~ng Address
City. Slate, ZIP City, State, ZIP
.
IPage ~?
--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
to grant the request for publiC meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to Ihe Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter 10 the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
JS)
C
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below 10 the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
r:~A 5-Z1-0Z "~%\~5~
Signature Date Signature Dale
J!.A l~ ? .5 l:i"YI rrt'/1 \)".-;~ ."S'-h..~~
Printed Name Printed ame
.322) ~~, 'tW jffi6~,~:5~~
Ma. '" Address Mailing Address
~ 77 _~oJJX~
ity. S te, ZIP City. 8dle. ZIP
~~\~'-... ~\\\\\Il"- '--':\1.1\,)1.. ~l ~~ Q ,
Signature Dale Sirature ~
\. "'~ \"C. ~\~\'\\;'f\L \~M(e,,", LbWce(-J
Piinled Name Prinled Name f
U:'i":~\~ ~\lt. ~~\ J,,{) Ir-. V St-(~
Mailing Address ~ess
~~0~p \.l\\\.\~ -r:~ltatelf 77~J
6-')ro). t 6"-27-<h.-
Date Signjlt~re I Date
~ c\+h~ 4IMJ~r
~
3 2l.{ Ca..",(l~
Mailing Address-(UJto.s '77 If' ~
~llP
..; ;,21- ~
Date
Printed Name
liD I 0 ~ S1l2.t-'t.T
~.ailin Addres
. U /1l{q3
City, S ZIP
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
v r~6-E $L-
-....
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuefa, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1. to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proPOSed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
{{;?:.:/~ S;.,ZN~'{, 11.- I 1.0 LJ ~-27-0"
R ICHA-IZ.O L.6of1l L...E.. V C ;C /J1t/L- ~ b 1 P-1Yl 'Ie 'I
Printed Name Printed Name (
Z 102. 77foAfPS<?N 02"<>Ss4V~ 1,J. fV tf I r ~ 1tJ4R~( (II,;;
Mailing Address O,e, Mailing }\,ddress
'1r 1r:MJk.t4 IX /7&)7/
City, State, Z/
..e./C.//M6~//.J ...e'xAS 77tU9
City, Slate, ZIP l -C7s<1
3)
Signature
Date
4)
Signature
Date
Prinled Name
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, Slate, zr p
City, Stale, ZIP
5L
Signature
Date
6)
Signature
Oale
Printed Name
Printed Name
r--
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
City, State, ZIP
r--
r-
Vfj..c:;,..ftl: 3d
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
f ;' "A..h'.J .,,;:'
V1) d../,,/:;d!;/I ..it ~-I/-("'2. '( ~ ~ S-Jl/-Od-
Signature / Date Sig ture Date
l-lar&/.l t. Cr~,q :s;:.... . -r;".(/(<:, Rld/A\t'
Prinled Na.~i ...dl Printed Name
/8 lti.f/~?C Vc?/s 1;;.1 Ave. Jc
Mailing Address /' Mailing Address
JlOc/S.J.o~, 7;C- "77DJ.T &/ 0."'1'0. 7X ??IfJ1
City, Slate. ZIP . City, State, ZIP .
~) 1Z:h1~{I. -I, aJ/\ !J-Jf-{)J.- { (/4J., tb-,Jn.._n/ f)-/8-{J]/
'Signature . Date Signature ./ OJ --~ . '1' Date
tit~~~ C. ('~r(f;,y../ Printed Nameb A
I'J Vi 7/ a. fA- t, [) aJC!> 1706 t:l1ft OAt<. L-A vf,..
Mailing Address -r-V Mailing Address
-lit%tt!fr, l)OSj C~~la~I~PO TV: 77Cf37
ii) ~:#~~~/~ ~~ "f-/J-/~
.gnalure Date ur ....... Date
13/11 f(,~ur .YAX tc),j,,{erl
Printed Name Printed ame
9,)./ fire. K It):' / ~ J'7?
Mailing Address Mail;ng A;jlress
kJ &,,,p ~ 7i 11<1 ~ 1 tJ~ ~ 7;lj/,f/
City, Slate, ZIP' I City, State, ~I~ ~ -
r--
r-
r-
, ,
.I v'1::r1'2- :3.(;,
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, laDonna
Castsouera, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sailas. We beseech the
Executive Director;
1. to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by lelter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection ASSOCiation;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning Proposed dis harge permit no. 04001.
~
Signature / Date
VI!. S. ~~ 'ilL
Printed Name /
S':;f &>t1~ly $&if s
Mailing Address f
qil..f h..JJtlHM 1??f''l
City, State, ZIP
~~1I1'1J.(~C2..
Signature V Date
~ 1J DPF"\/'c.J::.~L1
Printed Name .--
:ur;:xX.( ~~y 1"12.
Mailing Address
~,. l.N;:}c,q. Tx II "1i "')
City, State, lIP
.:, ~ p-~ ~~-.,
~Signature Date
/"P~ ~~"L'...,.y
Printed Name '
--p"t~ f.~
. ature
/l.. KtNO;J,) 6-. tit" r..f
Pri led Name
/07, J) .iJol/Jl "7'
Mailing Address
,.feu s loA; ;-.,1(
City, Stale, ZIP
/
4)
.,"U)~~
#~}2-
Date
'OL
Signatu Date
E,L. +hc. IY\ I \c.~f.. \l
Prinled'Name
~(~L{I':>lA f)~.
Mailing Address
H6u<;.to~ 7)1. '7 7 C1~-:>'
City, Slate, ZIP
~ C1 A-L. lk W Jt'
Si~at~edc.s D. \.J ;-11- Date
Printed Na~
nl:.'J..{" HeQ.', t~H.
Mailing Address
t.0rzt~~ .JX 71598
City, Slate, Zl P "
.;J.s30Cl .sr H'MJY /"7Z
Mailing Address
~r/ ~"""'.,.. 1';(" 7797"
City, Slate, ZIP
~-Io- ()~
Dp.
r-
r-
P.4-&a. :s 7_
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was rnade by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
1~?re~~~Jp./~ ~?/D~ ~ S~ fr~
;;;AVJP~ (~)p1. r/ Yl.} ~ah(>R-f- I/"JI""$
rinted Name Printed Name
/1, /fr, '\ t& '5 t: (ft1'f4lio ) I R It;; /l cI 51.
MaiiinQ Address ':/ Mailing Address
Po,,! LaI.H:l.~ 17<:' 77Cf 77 ~~f. L~v~.d, T,k 77'f7?
City, State, ZIP / City, State. ZIP
~,~~~ ,f-d'/.oz, < (j Ic~- -
Signature Date ~nalure
J)b/Z.;5 CAskftrtt () hI G.1"'l-~
Printed Name I Printed Name
17~6 l/IJ€. tJn.k l,,) ~ ') d.1o r<"' ~-\{" L......
Mailing Address Mailing Address J
~) IdA! f'1 N. 77if3 7 t \ ~..--t' ~ T..... (") ,rs --;
City, Stale, ZIP City, Stale. ZIP
~~ =~~: :::~1<2 (, 0- ;J. !l~
ignalU~ .' Dale Si~lure. ' Dale
-'r.- ,__ _ _ .IJelUI to ^\ I tc bLlL
Prinled Name Printed Name
,Jur tIt'st",-
J Tx 71tJt3
5/"3'~.2
Date
~z.q- (. L
Date
1F-'2-"'-O~
7:~ Z V M~ lJu.vL
Mailing Address
+=:\ C ~pO T't.-71c.8J
City, Slate, ZIP
.-J t;lA 7
Mailing Address
Htil.Jsi-c.v
City, state. ZIP
r-
r-
'"
,/ .~?)
Page ~
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We. the undersigned and affected citizens, appear to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonne
Casteiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for dlsputad hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
-:, (la~ ~j1~ sj,~:
Signature ate Signature
(l>u';'t- 'i- t'J t< 'i LL 'I-
Printed Nam Printed Name
91'1 ~e5e ~
~ng ~ "'C< 77V~ 7 Mailing Address
City, Slate. ZIP City. Slate. ZIP
~. \ ) ~ L{ n l}/ 5,.) 7-lJ( 41
Slgnalure JV- ~ Date Signature
V~~tJo" c;. iced;l
Printed Name
'2/'3.1 Co-.-t.-I?-c:.-I$. ~.
Mailing Address
C ~ X>-7V1 fO (:> T><
City, Slate, ZIP ,
Date
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
777'Tl
City, State. liP
5) 6)
Signature Dale Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
"...--
r
P#<':s-Fi. 3> 55
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaOonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public: meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2, to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
\
V I ' .., A V'
1)' .OlflLIJltu,'/V'CV21
Da~ gn u
Printed Name
I?)./ "2,</31"
Mailing Address
{JY1rkfl W 77iff>rp
City, Stale, ZIP
{-Ji.?-4, ~ ;..#~ .tJ-/9-6J...
~nature Date
~;~~m~iL~t'V' ~
.:J'5~n(e ..5t.H-:J l1l. t;11e. N, tJt/IIMlJ/fJF
~ng Address Mailing Address
'j""'C'l.--L l OWe/:\. \eV 1'1919 ~(T J..IJI/~14 ;A 17'119
City, Stale. ZIP City, Stale, ZIP
V" Sll/;d,,,1' ~r-< {,lfi::.t ~
~~;~:!,~1I4 <( y 1 -zE N:! ~
~() W s41Q;h~-<l.- 12"1"2... g~ ::ns1>
~fjling Adfress Maikng Address
f.!ClJJ.')io",:Iy. -noo~ [L~;1;, 1) )?1J7
City. Slate, ZIP City. Stale. Z''''
Printed Name ./i .
iV/ (I(HrOle4 Tra~
Mar~np AdJiiss 7
.L-{ ~~. qcOJ(C:<:: 18" {~O2.
City, S . ZIP
~ I~~O J.!I{~ 5"-.{7~~
Signature ~ Date
hFJ./NlS J.lf..,~o/l9 ry
Printed Name
5 'US'-oz..
Date
,
Vpage ef 0
/"
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerK of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001 , which was made by letler to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed h..rlng concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carsncahua Bay Protection Association;
r
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
tJ,) s~~~h .~~ad ~~1s~77~~nature
0e R R\/ /JL~ V ATY
Printed Name , Printed Name
~3
Mailing Address Mailing Address
~L ~ N'\~ll ;\EJ
City. Slale. ZIP . City, State, ZIP
Date
4)
Signature
Date
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
~~~ 4)
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r--
Ne, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 10 grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
conceming proposed discharge perrnit no. 04001.
l;)~Y~V-.5k~l- ~~~~ s-jlIICl.}"
, Signature Date Signature Date
&,...$ R~/.!h:.s.e- 1>\AI\.lE \<'CE~NER.
Pnnted Name Printed Name
rz,03 (!TY.ep gO,! I\/.
r Mailing Address
/JJ,er 4w"h'4" 7ft 7791,/
~lale, ZIP
l ~1fik0~o'ce-
slrat~ Date
ffll- l..~.DW;) 6>~w
;~N3e~ bL
Mailing Address V
Jlu~>7In Ictlf/ "115731
. Slate, ZIP I
~)...-
Dale
S,gnature
J
Printed Name
?2. \ \ WI\il.?17t:A l <.:sr
Mailing Address
~LN 11: 'filo3
City, State. ZIP
\db':l c.:~. ~t::.,. N.
Mailing Address
~c\tt LA\lA(.A, \~
City, State, ZIP
~L~"~~~
Signa ure
G&..e.1J'A f2f:6.€~S
Printed Name
3:)..11 WflR.R6U
Mailing Address
~~;n:z~~ 'lg703
1-1-~"T1
05- \I . O~
Date
8=-1) . b"2-
Date
s
.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed THRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
Lf~
Ne, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A_ Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the requnt for public meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
~/~ f. _~.
Signature Date
7]}c ",td WrJ..1 ~
Printed Name =:7-
l~Di" w~f 4vT'
Mailing Address
J)VS /,~ liC '79:7 f} (
City, State, ZIP'
I.
3) ~:~ UWl'-.JL 512-0J.- 4)
IQnal Date
~diL;<n~
((;00 ~ 'N?O~; ",m fj., <IrA .
Mailing Addre$t
,%\1(\ 11- "19'/02;,
City. Stale, ZIP
Signature
Dale
. ~ ~;~~~-
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. State. ZIP
Signeture
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
5) 6)
SIgnature Date Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, Stale, ZIP City, Slale, ZIP
.
/Page q 3>
-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citjzens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, laDonna
Castanuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
r--
~) ~., (L ~._,7" 5/zr,/o,z... ~ &>/,</;;(dp;?Q>5"-:'d'7'o~
Signa ure Dale Signature DaTe
'7;)..,;" Wft,-r...uL>Lrtf- ,11",( A'. ./'t..4.J://-",,...,.5>
Printed Name Prinled Name
I 0 ~ ~..( .2:..t -,; / -11/. .5; "- f
Mailing Address '..? ~/CC"L>Ac.. <:..~/.::. C
Mailing Addre s
.4...." r",,;. ""'Ii< 75'74,(" .J;A.?cb 7";.;.
City. Stale, zip City, State, ZIP
~Oi/~;1 !l)~ ,5b7ItJ~ ~)j{(jjp tlt(d(UJ,f1tJ.~ 5-d7 Od
'7f,gnaye Date SIgnature Date
0'.44 Whlh,{)pr tJ. Lal, s:.. m ( dill j A",:J
Prinledl;Jame Printed Name
lli 1 Red f;ud TIL
Mailing Address
Rru:s1/fJ Tl( 787~
City, Slate. ZIP
7,57/
l'-Ild ~~r(10E0\(' \rde)
Mailing Address
\)AIMJ~ Tx 7Io~1f
City. State, ZI
5) 6)
Signalure Date Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State. ZIP City, State. ZIP
-.
V Page ~p
r--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge perrnit no
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2,2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
Mailing Address
FL C~a),
City. Stale, ZIP
/2
7'K "/7'fJ?
i
:;
J::::hwo tJo"-de~ l'"\
Printed Name
--E1L&'i. ~e1
Mamng Address
~. f,:t:.'f,~)~ T1LI31
v:- z. ~..o 'V" A(
Dale Sig
;A/D-
5r$rO~
Date
r-
.1 j} -..-..? y1 L S""-:lJ-d2..
1) ~'<...,~
Signalure Oate
BAUr ((. M,~f:J(JenJ
Printed Name
[J.d. BtJ'< 6~?
Printed Na~
-10.
6"- 2-~ -07--
lS'tIB
'.
r
,;
PA-~~. Lf6
r-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for pUblic meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed diSCharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
..r; .-') ~-~/ t:R;- ~-d!5a... ~"n... );;,;I;..L
Signature Date. ture
TE~~ y #. WL~S S--Fy.."'~Je"" Ku.foc), ~'I'lf-o ~
Prinled Name rint Name
s-z..rt.o c:-
Oale
/1/-1 (.A/I'I/.-~#f-"'-E ~r !?f:2.84IJ9/)
Mailing Address Mailing Address
E~ c. -1-/0 r~ ""7 ?~:f? fl ('~~(JD 7'(HS 77\lo~ 7
City. State, ZtP City, Slate, ZIP
. :a- 5-d~'O~) ~Po-L ~ -1J;:-/L.,. .s:J..t-o?-
S'gnature Date Signature Date
S"Ai\-\.....S L~c.fJ~rr"ylC c.L'lJ/.l~~ STc/,.,o
Pnnted Name Printed Name
~T: <I gDY?t e...t.f{.'~Js+- /.l..c ~J $~ I ~f
Maol,ng Address Mailing Address
t;L,C.lHYJfo Ti 7 ?<{J7 ~ ~ 71'+ 5"S
City, Slale, ZIP City, State, ZIP
,("'~~;;t~S-"'''4< (1"'" ,_I'I {" './_ S"'<'H
Signature Date ~ Date
Edt.JClV?J~ 6..o.vc> fCq.""hr".,..) ~50o.)utG: z...
Pnnled Name Printefl Name
~O:<) E. ..J.J; [I ; e. S~. RT ? AQ,K /V':J.
Ma'ILng Address B I" rlaj~ng IlCldress
~l ~~~ 17l.l~) E/ C...._J'o Z.....~ ~Y3?
Crty, State. ZIP City, Slate. ZIP r
r-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
-
vp~'Z- 4-7
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
r-
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
. j
~)17...ohL.,.....\~~Q ~.2j-c:fl.2)
~. Date Sig ure
.RqLPH tJDV~J>.O
Prinled llfame
\601 :rv..O~
Mailing Address
!t~~r IX 77t.J37
\) 0~L ~ 5'.?X-dl..
Signature Dale (\
~ 01 Jj~ (1). A. H:\/.) /!'::L :::r~
Printed Name Printed Name
y.t? t;~ /4/Z- 21ot.. f-iu-r-C'_~,~ ~
Mailing Address Mailing Address
C~~ta~P<? if ?7H? ~~ta~,~fb' ~ "/ 7J./.~'7
\~ Q.jJ~ 5-')'6-0:l~ti.~ o. -1.,. ]9..L 5<1<j_oJ.
Signature Date ignature Date
/YI il.\l..r.\J A. P.4l.kE;Lijf J"A-IlI.~<; II.. <;.... T"H
Printed Name Printed Name
~;(()Co ~ ti./J A r;ta",,-~
Mailing Address -
a ~;) "Tx ?7ifJ7
City, Slate, ZIP
$'"".2.i'-o~
Dale
P4VLl
Prin ed Name
N <I ~O)("" .:LS'-I)
Mailing Address
EL ('Htt"I~O
City, Slate, ZIP
J
4)
6"',Z9.0:(
3alD4- 5TftrE. Il; t 1 do
Mailing Address
G.4NA-Oo . Tv. 'J"?'1lo :A -1?5"~
City. Slate. ZIP
r--
vP fr6--~ _1- g .
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to ltIe Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaOonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
"i)~: // p~/~d'~;h'~ ~. ~::~S/Z'~2
S'9nature Oate ~1ure U Dale
Cd~~k~ ~ ~ y
Printed Name Printed Name
711 5'"" PJ,D~j;..~~ ~ '-f 15 f?n ~ 3 y s:
MaIling Address Mailing Address
EVA/d. ~J>(. 77~.s-7 ed~4 '"7-A? 7/<=].57
City, Slate ZIP City, S te, ZIP
\13).5:. {( , '!-]-- ~ ~ i ~.sh."/02-
S'9natur Dale S' ature Date
y,.,vL::tr/'vC~7 ...bhl\ S, SaM...le
/~ted Name Printed Name I
qtt<:/1,4~}""~') _"0.130'1' '8lfS
MaIling Address Mailing Address
fCOJv-A. ~J)0 9T? Edt-lfo I)c 77951
~ity, Slate, ZIP City, Stale, ZIP ,
, . . -. 5-";.l7-()~ sf f/furl./J IkcJ t7 5/tl1/(}:L
9 et ' Date Signature r. Date
~ Oo..\lid. .sc...~ ,..}.. ~t.-j. Ard.d
Pr,"ted Name ~ Printed Name
0.~ <SC\r,^-L.>> ')3")) f m d3~ }J.
Mailing Address Mailing Address
ELl",ll. Ix. l't~ &1m Tx -nc,S 7
City, State, zlp City, Stale, z,p1
PI9-6-/Z. ~ '1.-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
~
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Execu1ive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2. 2002, frorn Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
r-
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC malling list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
1) ~ tJ~S',)..'?-C.l 2)
~nature Date Signature
lSS?Jl1e-/ 0 Teqe/c/...
Printed Name -
PO 130 'f.. Sr9
Mailing Address
60110/0 T'i- 77r6;l
City, Slale. ZIP
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. Slate. ZIP
3)
4)
Signature
Date
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Printed Name
MaiUng,6,ddress
Mailing Address
City. Slate, ZIP
City. Slate, ZIP
5)
Signalure
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, State. ZIP
City, Slate. ZIP
/ PI>/3E. ill
~S-O
PETITION
Reg.tdlng Pro~ed THRec Disch.rge Permit No. 04001
We, the underaigned and a~ ciliDn.. appeal to (he Chief derk of THRCC, uDonna
Cutanuela. to delw.r our message to Executive DIredor Jeffrey A. Sallu. We lleaeedllhe
Ellecutive Director:
1 to grant the ...qUA' for public /llMtI"g concerning the pIOpOHd di&eharge permit no.
04001, whIc:tt was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of CtIrancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the req_t fOl' dl.putH ....r1ng oonceming the propoled diadlarge pannit
no. 04001, which was made by letI8r to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Mania of Carancahua Bay Prote<:tion ""oei.tion;
3. to edd uch of the underwigned at their addreaa below to the TNRCe malllngl"t
~-- ::~?f:.A- ~ 9':>7fdL
r;' ~'tWlE" h\ WI.~weo;'i
PrIntiId N_ rlnIIld N1IIne
J~' MClVtXJlilt..If~ l{.U /hI',! iJ,.f\-C-
Mlliting Address MaIling Address
/?'.CHfr1()Nt:) ~ 11c.N. "J r"" "1)~""Z;( 71 It)C
Cily. StIle. ZIP CitY. 5...., ZI .
3) 1JJ,.j 11. ~.r-~-I>;>" ~
~ 0Ite
1/..1... ~ /J./h ",tlG&.U:Jf!7:J.
PrinleCI Heme
01&'4 -t /)11:';;.""'''''! L "" C
Milling Adcltaa Mailing MdtMt
j1yc.-h;>r,nolDp."'#.ikIS '1?fUf ~k1h J)( 77<J.I.,'l
City, ~,ZlP )- CittO ~Ie, lJ: 11 I ()
il~~hJ~" \. ~"'.~ (' ~~ ~~~io2-
't^ ~;... ) ~u\".\L 4iz>...I.M'1'l
Prin Heme - ~lecl NMie
~~~d~~\~~ .
a;f~~'z,l.J \~ ) 1 ~o ~
,--.
,;
Page {i;" (
r-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clem of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
of e undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC malllng list
posed discharge permit no. 04001.
v ~
1l 2)
~ Signature Date
f;,~
Pnn .Name ~ ReO Prinled Name
r-
~~
?6CJt Mailing Address
,.~J 1ry,
City. State. ZIP City, State, ZIP
3) 4)
Signature Dale Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP City, State. ZIP
5)_ 6)
Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP City, State, ZIP
/ r2-
Page ~
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association:
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
< tJJ" >';:'~aY' ~ ~ Je. 1kdJZiJ- 'hl!o/-
Signa Dale Signature Date
Joh'}n'1 ;r. ,{,dhr f/A/f)A}(, ;iu/t,(r
Printed Namel Prinled Name
'7 1.-11 r!~ r; /,,~,/ '2.../3 f4trij,()1(
Mailing Address Mamng Address
;-/.7v,fo/Vj -;;: 7-1D30 /lor;,/, -tP'pIU 710"30
City. State, ZIP City, State, ZIP'
4)
Signature
Date
3)
Slgnalure
Prinled Name
Maifing Address
City, State, ZIP
5)
Signature
Prinled Name
Mailing Address
City. State, ZIP
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
Date
6)
Signature
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City. State. ZlP
......
PAt.-d- 5"3
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
r
We, the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to EKecutive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for publiC meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Cieri< dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
;) 3c_:-S
Signature
:57-~ V~N .:5:
Printed Name
:,~~~~ (,~,:>,~..~<J'./c>~
Signature D'ate' Dale .
;)1E1Zt1Al 13. lfJ.'U'<GTlfJ/t., ~~'A 2. a-". lLoT
Printed Name Printed Name
K'r.3 4M J ';3 8 ''"R,.? ~O~ \~~ e:.
Mailing ~dress Mailing Address
,c;t- C-MJAJ. 7A' '7'7'1.3'7 t;.. ~"-<./Io 1)(.. -n'\~1
City, Slate, ZIP' City, Slate. ZIP
. .!Y~y~,) I
U. --: h.. 4) 'j.,-;"" ~ j~A~ -
Oa\e .:SigoaMe
&h.,I.....
Date
r-
WEIIVI!f:II1It.-/L
V'T("", 4IVcI~..~.,...
Printed Name
'''6 Ou",", It',,,~
Mailing Address
P ...T LA.,....... 1l.
City, Slate, ZIP
77"".
~f~~re~~.r 7/
tl7(')/,P! 71' ?'7~$
City, State, tiP
,--
VS) ~ U.....J. . . "JIr s /-z.,,1 02... 6)
Signalure Dale Signature
fomw'lI!? /f W~/AI#EIn1..--c...d"'
Printed Name Printed Name
~ ~,&Yi'/W
Mai ing ddress Mailing Address
LtXN.fe, 7A' '7'7~S
City. State, ZIP City, Slate. ZIP
Date
~
.,L
?~I#-
~~
--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the requestfor public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001. which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
cof1iJ~ri'ling1prQPosed ischarge permit no. 04001.
4..."...4..-..'..'......,.,..-.
,
I
1./ 3)
aturiP>'>' '
~i ,.It;
Prinled Name
/97 II!~JlA// _-r;,'41~N 1/.;61/
Mailing Address
PoRT lA1/IJ4A, ~ 77f1!
City, State, ZI P
.
6-3-1>1/4)
Dale
2)
Signature
Date
Ponied Name
,r-
Mailing Address
City, Stale, ZIP
ignature
1#;11ff>~ <)11'1
Pnnted Name I Printed Name
~!ll!ie~~ ~# JbJ II 0')'1 lie. Mailing Address
Ibrl.b~t~. t; 21.1}'7D
City, Stale, ZIP' /1 City, State, ZIP
Signature
Date
5) 6)
Signature Date Signature Date
Printed Name Printed Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
,
.
V Page r f!)
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens. appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002. from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
0') ~'\U~~i""\ ()....h~'R-IlD~~-:a.,/<M ~eye..> b/#
Signature Date Signature Date
C(;;II/~vn:.}...o UtZ..:, I 7-.- ""Ro~ Ge1.r>-.J1I.,..pD .B.Il.'1"'''''~'' jA4~,v1::?,liJ
Printed Name Printed Name
3<1 IS I(~ u/6:- If;r KP,4-J:; }.CJ6L1-1J +7~9 ~
Mailing Address Mailing Address
':-(J'i,.vY7"t:>t5'-/.CJ14-P.'"11;..oJ.i,. 77 '--fJ..f~ (r~=...r,..,,"o ~V>4,':S I '"?'''rA:-
Cily, Slate, ZIP' City, S~t ZIP /
C /6, O-r 'ft-.. ..
3) fj ~o..rtl"1. .11.,,,,,,,()(~ c?/l1D
Signature ~ e
t::....,.JO-...=rrl" k>FS.y""",,-c;n.r-I""L E"Ck~~~ R''L--r'lk'- Up."r,~I!!.:
Printed Name Printed Name
:;,"i1b~ t.JJfE.s./ ";I::.O,8c>
Mailing Address
3<~ b L/-f;
Mailing Address
H~'-rl'r~-r-JI'S--12, IX 1'4Lq~
CIty, State, ZIP
Lt:,c;i'):;!L~:J"t
,8"",.
~ '"'
jf~p,$T:~-~~ ly77 ~'b
Zily. State, ZIP
5) 6) --._--~-~
Signalure Date Signature Date
Printed Name Prinled Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
Cily, Slate, ZIP Cily, Slate, ZIP
.
.
/page M
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, laDonna
Castaiiuela. to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
--
1 10 grant the request for publle meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no, 04001 , which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
co,ncerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
~ >II7!/fttdu~ 1~ ')'d 2h~k/tzJ-
'Q~re Dale I
[~ f))ifcl\icnn ..:lilY) IJrfif5
Printed Name Printed Name
1~9 Gruoevm€.., No IhfJ:1J DUlIlfS f},.(ltlf.---
Mailing Address r Mailing Address
, (}/OStf,c! Ti 11632-
City, Stale, 2!lP
Ir-
3)
Signature
Printed Name
Mailing Adoress
City, State, ZIP
5)
Signature
Prinled Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate. ZIP
Date
Date
7.)"'f}2.
Date--
4)
Dale
Signature
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
6)
Signature
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP
.
--
r-
nage 5 7
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castaiiuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
V1Tt?/flTl"- ~ "j:.,2J-e>Lv{{ \t-/Z-bL,N0 uhn~ b.iJ/-()t
Sig ature Dale Signature Date /
~I'-n/...j /.4w Ff(It/JGe~ 1JJ~
'1W1ed Name Printed Name a~,
C4'i I'~=- C M;41tJc,f (.I,,/I, ::7 t<-fC.
"<~/nn.(.Msr .t1A'I.s""'/~ J!)~ ;J.01'~ td.6/>.ys;..;aR.e f;LL-
Mailing Address Mailing Address ~
JJU.-..lc.'as 7i ?7~LI- A--L#&/d'...5 71<. '77~r;~
City, State, ZIP City, State, ZIP
V~b 4-;;)fbj~ (, }?ti",v2;J 'Jll~j) ~~
"Ig ture /Date 'gn ture.~
MIRY" c. IIY/~Jlr () lIJJI1Ni T/1 11(.j)f)I/JJ~
Prinled Name Printed Name
,7.~S:- J4$i 13~Y5j,PrL- [Jr, 2 .6/~ (! I? t;; J:l
Mailing Address fo.1ailin dress
?" J ~C/--".s 7X 77 '1(,,5-- L c:. /()~. e
City, Slate, ziP ity, Slate, ZIP
~) /}fku.9IJ, 9 !:JtJ4.~/{;-/I~'~~~ /)ltt,~ to-II-C),
Signature Date Signature te
(}/e.tVd<t... IJ'Mo1Ilo~ fJ ~ /.. filiI'. /J'J fll?k.l. c r
Printed Name Printed Name
,5'7"7 g~,u;,,,) /5/c.(" .f3~t/~iJz,
Mailing Address ~dress .
P~hlk0 ..t.; 77<j.(;',S'" V/~<!,,-<v,~J.ya4- 7 7'1~.$
City, State, ZIP .~ City, Stale, ZIP /
.....
as Ztf6s
V;age (;)~
--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
CastaiiueJa, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
r-
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list
concerning proposed discharge permit no. 04001.
-1) '~fl"'d4 iJJ.,"TT"'~ L II- lJoo;).J 2)
Signature Date Signature Date
.r)Dr"1~ Pe.i;.,/cson
Prinled ame Printed Name
..?O~ Ari'l'lwherr-J
Mailing Address Mailing Address
'-PalIUIC-J 7y 7 7'/~-
City, Slate. ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
~ g",,~--I'-r~A_ -J,t/"'r~,j 6-11<4/P-........
Signature Date Signature
B 1-=1 f'?t.3ci r A ,5 -I- ~o vd
Printed Name Printed Name
Date
t 'f,;./V: ,fu', /3,d'l L,_, ,~:. 1,,_,
Mailing Ad(jrtlSS
~ ~?
7t;:rJf:le, 10 ~ !.O( ~. 7'.( <'- "
Citll. State. ZIP
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
5)
Signature
Date
6)
Signalure
Date
Printed Name
Printad Name
r-
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
City, State, ZIP
~age ~
r
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appea'lo the Chief clerk of TNRCC. LaDonna Caslaiiuela, to deliver
our message 10 Executive Director Jeffrey A Sailas. We beseech the Executive Direclor:
to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permil no. 04001, which was
made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
2. to grant the request lor disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permil no. 04001, which
was made by letter 10 the Chief Clerk daled May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
~.
3 to add each of the undersigned at their address below to Ihe TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permit no. 04001.
1I1j\..~UL~G-/
Si nature
I)IJSS Jf/-)... ' ,RA/) JY
Prinled Name
Malt/ke! V ~ ~
}:j., tturtM lKI- '171/3'[
cjty~State, !(p-
t -!I-~v{., ~t.~ 0 ~ t. -/f-~ r-
Date Si al re ~ Dale
J1 It a If t ~r KAtI,v
Pnnled Name
Jp~ j."K If
Mailing ddress
!/~ ~ 1fi.. 11f.J1
3L
Signature
4)
Signature
Date
Dale
Printed Name
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP
City, Slate, ZIP
5)
Signalure
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Prinled Name
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
r-
City, Slate, ZIP
City, State, ZIP
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 307S, Port Lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
V:age ,/; 0
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Caslanuela, to deliver
our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sailas. We beseech Ihe Executive Direclor:
to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by letler 10 the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Proleclion
Association;
2. to grant Ihe request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge perrnil no. 04001, which
was made by letler 10 the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permil no. 04001.
:X)~~~.~L,11
Signature ' ~
Pf.>NID fJ-. fl'<L.-rMAt-J
Printed Name .
2)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
"1"7+1 WI'5<-rEia..wC'QP ~ '
Mailing Address
Mailing Address
_Dr1~LkSJ -r~ 1';:'1.-;"'$
City, State, ZIP
City, Slate, ZIP
4)
Signature
Date
Dale
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZI P
Date
6)
Signature
Date
Printed Name
Mailing Address
City, Slale, ZIP
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 307S, Port Lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
tAage E
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna
Castanuela, to deliver our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Saitas. We beseech the
Executive Director:
1 to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no.
04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris
of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
2. to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit
no. 04001, which was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken
Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address bel w
concerning prop~sed discharge permit no. 04001
~'fY\V.rJ~~ 6~~o~ I
~ Date
iJl}/~' I
,V. -'-~t>p
rinted Name . -
~S. G.~J')",.~
~g Address '--=t"""
tt rl Lot 0U' 6. '?X Il1.E
Cit'lSfafe. ZIP
~/' ~d~<~
\.-/~ignature
:;;E 1),4f(C4 If
Ponied Name
Or-- /;., hL
, D'ate
~)
.:2bt- tu t"#ttl"S5
Mailing AddreSs
dAll1t 17 '?7H 7
7iJfatW c; ~;:r6L
]ature Date
of) !.Ai NfIJlIJ[~
Printed Name
d/IJ W !.. 4;1;1l'%5:.
Mailing Address
mJA, r>c, 77'fs?
City. Stale, ZIP
C mailing list
. 1)[
rinled Name
-'..803 JJ NJIlJ((() if' If
Mailing Address
'tdfli;~ \W. rf1o'f
CILUL
". .' ~"p-~J-
s~4e Date
/- ~~~.-()-
Printed Name
10 (, j...."" 0",""1.. $..../ L..--
Maili~ Address
/60 t!:y/, " 'IY 1 $00 In
City, State, ZIP
~hJlI~ ~-;:J~~.;.
~re Date
mil j). o~/lC//J
'j;ze?9/
''&cti;:s ;X 719~/
City, State, ZIP
,..--
r
--
FRO'! : VerdBntMedjB
FAX NO. : 613 668-929'3
Jun 102002 1l:24F1'1 P2
Lffage b 2-
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We. the undersigned and l.lfected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Casta;;u.la, 10 deliver
our message to Executive Jirector Jeffrey A. Sililes. We beseed'I the exeeuthte Director:
1. to grant the reque.1t for publk: meellng conce~ the proposed disCharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by letter to b Ie Chief Clerk daled May 2. 2002. from Ken Morris of Carancahua eay PI'Ql8Ction
ASsOCIation;
2. to grant the reque.! for disputed hearing c:cncerning \he proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which
was made by lette,' to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Caraneahue Bay Prolecbon
Association;
3. to add each of the undersigned at their address below to the "THRee mailing list concerning propOsed
diaoharga ~ roo 04001.-
tA; .q~l].:i:f;;(i- 1/~/fX,2$AlllidLllJM1Qwd;(c / !qIO~
",gr'fi~. Pate S'llnalure Date PI'" Ii L,J\,
j~\ec1vCl;2CL11\ . ~Mltt( D,RrA+lk~-d!,
Pnnted N~ 1 "i.J 'D..1. J. . Printed Name
~?j\~..'::S'J~~ JlfOq ma'l1of' lJJ.iilt'"
M Ing Adelress ~ -.., Moiling Adel",..
. '. '~-A- 17~99, R.nc'#'r'lfw'''j;L., Ti '(?:-J
tv, State, ZIP" i . City, Stale, ZIP
~ 'iJl:%./fl-;~r#z..~ 6 L.:-
~gna re ate Signature
4/.J...R l A,/."t 6WS k j' . 7{phar-k B- 6-/'01:",.....
Pnnllod me . Printed Nama
t/~I.~ 1/.4-Zt /fr- '2303 f..;dv-.J) ~rv r..r
MailIng MdreS6 Mailing Address -r-
;:/4'~-::/r7j'~77t?$.~l-,"d;,.,.e-;!" r>&' '7 7~6?"
City. . ZIP City, State, ZIP
~ ~~ 1? ~ ~1o.tJ-ft'~d
-JJJN'arne <P , r Ol~; q,
3~3 t,(~ III'llUlrl t='~r~ tT
M8Il1ng Address .", .
~{~ .ull",d.~ itlfl/1
City, State, ZIP
6...-7'-0.;2..
Date
Pooled Nam
~Oq,Jv1(tl'UI('Y:Y ..
~~i~~4'11
City, S .
Please retum to CBPA. 213 CR 3078, Port lavaca. TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
~ "'!;L
Page -6-3.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRee Discharge Permit No. 04001
we, the undersigned e" a~c1ed citizens. appsal to the Chief cieri< of TNRCC. LeDonna Castanu8le, to de.var
our m8f<8age to Execuliv I OirectOr Jeffrey A. Saillls. We beseech t... ExecutiVe DirectOr.
1 to grant t~e rllQu tat for publiC meeting concerning the proposed diseharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by ieller to the Chief Cieri< dated May 2. 2002. from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Prote<:tion
Association;
2. 10 grant the ,equl8t for dlaputecl h..rlng concerning the proposed diseharge permit no. 04001. which
was made by Ie~ ir 10 Ih. Chief C'el1< dated May 2, 2002. from Ken MQI1ilI 01 Carancahua Bay Protection
Aosociation;
3. to add each of lh . undersigned at their address below 10 thlliNRCC
discharge ~rmit no, 04001.
'v9> ~"i"'. ~
Signature
/J,.....c.~ r
Printed Name
...{>k h'u~i ~-'i:P~.{
nature '. Oate
AroYl p\\( 5J.eWtl rt
Printed Name
.'L~g l!Al,^~., L.... ~I(' Tali.fST
Malnng Addnll's m AddrtS/l
~~Ql"iD~T;(,774-('5 t./I~/C)~! 'R 71t!is-
. ClI>'. Stale. ZIP I ' Citv. SllIle, ZIP
~~~)$~ ~~dJ
Dale ',nre Oa
.>r-~WA"'-~ vj:?~?C. ~k.,;: fie
Printed Name
3;;07, ~I~ .........Q ,n. .~ ti:
Mailing Ad real
2.:1 fi n:5.(...... --
Mailing Address
1....
City. Slate. ZIP
S)~ I,t! .,~, .
Signature ~
~-:sJ!. 01"1-
Prin~d~. ~~I.
I?'
MlIlDn9Addrau
,,*Ik ,'n ~ N 7?~f"r
City. S1a18. ZIP
J . . 6. ~-<.
~n.lur. Oate
$<tAC, C _~.........("+ S C"
Printed Name
e.a "}S"".12 ~"..P.-vo::./<l
MaiUng Address
I{</............ Tx ? 7o~ ~
City, Slate, ZIP
,,-. Please return to CSP'" 213 CR 307$, Port Lavaca, TX 77919 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
06-{1-02 09 AN FROM MOSLEY TILE CD
TO 361 893 5394
PO
Page -1i!:I
PETITION
Regarding Proposed THRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We. the unoe"'lgned and atlected citiZens. appeal.., the Chief ell'" of THRCC, l.aDonna Ca&lanueta, to deliver
our l1\4lSsage \0 Execuwe Director Jeffrey A Saitaa. We beaeec/l the ExecuIIVe Director:
1 to granllhe rvquest for pubnc melting concerning the propoied diSc/1a'lle permit no. 04001, whiCh was
maoe by Illller to the Chief Clerk daled May 2. 2002, from Ken Monis of Carancahua Bay ProtBCtion
Anoclation;
2. to grant the ,equ..t for dl.pulad hearing concerning the pt"opoted discharge parmI! no. 04001, whiCh
was made by I8tWr to tile ChillI Cieri< dMBd May 2. 2002. from Ken Manis of Carancahua Bay proteclion
AssocIation;
3. to add each of tile undeflligned at their addrass beloW 10 tha TNRCC mailing llet concerning proposed
<llScharge ennit no 04001
I
\-
1)
<~~.. f ~&eI(/4-
-1;lgn8 re ~
C!:i~fV (J1t?S I~
Print arne
7-atJ{). IbJrvJtvPlJ e'r
Mailing Addrl!$$
~~ 7Y.. 77of77
City, t.te. ZIP
''/I~z.
Signature Date
soh" 1"ll?.Jle-1
Printed Name /
/1,).. / &x (;).-t,
Mailing Addreu
/:~[:;;('~ 1st 77 tj ~7
~3)
d.l~".u //t--? t/lf-4')
SIgnature DB SlgMIUfll
(' hl:s7/jp~ /Jb6/G'i
Printed Name Printed Neme
7.2M.. l()~ M
MaiHng Address Mailing Add,,,"
~M.- ~_". ~)(. 77if /.,
City, late, ZIP , City. Stele, ZIP
Date
!
l
I
51 6)
Signalure Oale Sivnature
Printed Name Printecl Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, State, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
Oa.
Pleaae return 10 CBPA, 213 CR 3075, Port LavaCll, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
.
,
\ Page .b 'fJ
r--
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal 10 the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Caslaiiuela, 10 deliver
our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sallas. We beseech the Executive Director:
10 grant the request for public meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Associalion;
2. 10 granllhe request for disputed hearing conceming the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which
was made by letter to Ihe Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Proleclion
Associalion;
3. 10 add each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permit no. 04001.
r
~ 1~;at~~' "
::J;.:... /.<1m~{;'.:
Printed Name
1""0'( C':'Q.!''':N A^~~ t.AJ
Mailing Address
H~...,n:5", --r;t. 71r<-, z. ~
City, Slate. ZIP
t-If-I! :L
Date
~2)~~ 4th tA,
Sign re Date
~f)t7 ~ i]tr((p-!-e r
Prin ed Name
<<i'1Jbil/lLl'n~ ~~
:r}.ing Address
C~S~/~. 11179
~) "3w,,-,.h..\-v-. (,-l~-.~ 4)
Signature Date Signalure
~I\I ~ lLtU>*.......
Printed Name Printed Name
~6' b OAk lOw
Mailing Address Mailing Address--
s- Jl..\trn~ . n i!J..n.
City, State, ZIP . City, Slate, ZIP
5) 6)
Signalure Date Signature
Printed Name Prlnled Name
Mailing Address Mailing Address
City, Slate, ZIP City, Slate, ZIP
Dale
Date
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 307S, Port lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
.
\j Page t:.:-6
r"'
PETITION
Regarding Proposed THRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaOoona Castanuela, to deli.er
our message to Executl.e Director Jeffrey A Saitaa. We beseech the executive Director
10 grant the request for pUblic: meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no 04001, which was
mede by letter to Ihe Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahue Bay ProtectiOn
Association;
2. to grant the requeet for dlapuled h..rlng concerning the proposed discharge peJrnrt no, 04001, which
was made by letter to the Chief Cieri< dated May 2, 2002. from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
ASSOCiation:
3 10 add each of the undersigned at their addrelJS below 10 the TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permit no, 04001.
,-
ll11t C/~.((k.;,;
S'g ature
A^ .,. / .
.In, (' !.J.f.c'1{6"f.!
Printed Name
to () /'i.<'( . ].-{[;
Mailing Address
C4-;"f/J/i-Jo TV.. 77162-
City. Stata, ZIP I
'03) .~ 1, , 77 ( t)VIlJ.../\)
gnature . Date
-Kt'.r1€l', 61dr:'.S
Ponied Name
SO'1 L1/. fUlt'(!lmQI\
Mailing Address
Co f1c({l.c\ Tf 775' (, 7-
City, State, ZIP
'~~A P-i-' J... AJ L
5) ,. ~m.r(~ \i6) 14.,..,1~ ,{,J 1.#""'-...:"/
~nature Date Signature Date
t;hr."dr:; ,<:;-fqnc{ K
Printed Name
~F\ n
"j 'rf. I). 7
ailing Address
((II n",n rL T X 7 79&c.~
City. State, ZIP
k.}+t
Dale
~
2
ignature
L u.,t; liE
Printiid Name
~:,_~)
~-< I L _
Date
r
jJ{l 6<< 3:YO
MaIling Address
rJ,f 1. I,tMJc- / ~ t /'7 L. :L-
City, State, ZIP
~) c'1:r-J4- /Jt{('(rt.,\
Signature ~ /;/
(Ir\lt~ /-Ita vary U
nnted me
'J>:c.~ 8' ).
Mailin I\ddress
1~)/vJc, Tx 771& Z
~, State, ZIP
& -)
Date
Printed Name
Je. \5o~ J~ t
Melling Address
b-o-...:....<-.Ie ,Te<<-S -77C{c,"}.
City, Stale. ZIP
Please return 10 CBPA. 213 CR 3075, Port Lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
,-....
'J pagetf2.
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC DiScharge Permit No. 04001
We. the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Castaiiuela, to deliver
our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sallas. We beseech the Executive Director:
1. to grant the request for pUblic meeting concerning the prOposed discharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by letter to Ihe Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
AssOCialion;
2. to grant the request for dIsputed hearing Concerning the proposed disCharge permit no. 04001, which
was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
3. to add-each of the undersigned at their address below to the TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permit no. 04001.
r-
'"' 1) die- /..A;L 7-/6-t)';"
t:8ignature Date
...,;r;;(!m€S p. ~2K67L
Printed Name
;z.c; 4" V/.r7J<J h/ <!72.Mo..r;/9
Mailing Address
.,Jy,vR._._rr
City, Stale, ZIP
3)/~~
Signature
8;/1 WAi-Tf:R~
Printed Name
~
7.P,( //
7~ (7-02-
Date
(<J~ Z2. /JttJi/t~~
Mailing Address
~-fv,v 7fc 7.<7"9)
City, S_tat.y, IP
~)/MAJ If' 7./
Signature J ()! . Date
fYlflyt Ie J4,~, NCo,"",
Printed Name
<-( 8;,) ~ lvoo~j,~.,_ V, I~-o:.
M~I~g Address _ _
~"/'-,\'-OO I X 773 'IS
City, St!ii/;, ZIP I
~)JkM k_J
Signature
7
):;-/7 :"02-
-Baie-
((nf'7UT ST(2.1 c..t.L/JI\./()
Printed Name
\
4)
21/;19 Ml fJ-1I.""t5" i?~
Mailing Addres
~r~ IX -nt-/L.{'t
City, St te, ZIP
I!u.t OtJ
Signature ,
R:"" f J: #Yf&-h
Printed Name
IZ~~
7/17/,,-
Dat€.
Jl09d ,4.1,,11011
Mailing Address
~s. T'I." 771z.9
City, tate, ZIP
O~)'s,g{6d~
~ 4. fllVE.Y
Printed Name .
Ifr3 <6u.,k JoN
Mailing Address
Pit./l,iJ5,^, TKo 77{1'1
City, State, ZIP
7 ./7 0"2..
Date
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 3078, Port lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
.
~page ,b q
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affecled citiZens, appeal to the Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Castaiiuela, to deliver
our message to Execulive Director Jeffrey A Saitas. We beseech !he Execulive Director:
1 10 granl the request for publiC meeting conceming the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, whIch was
made by letter to the Chief Clerk daled May 2, 2002, 1rom Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
2 to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which
was made by letter to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
r
3 to add each of Ihe undersigned at their address below to !he TNRCC mailing list concerning proposed
discharge permil no. 04001. '\1) , A. / r#.. _
"1) ~I.., ~.~b&'t. "2~ 7f!)/II~
Signature Date Signatu'd1 Dale
~"~M l)1N~~(" ~(IL- ~;./-~
Ponied Name Printed Name
ZH~ 11(.1.\1.111.5 .J,n~ ;;1"113 ~ k
Mailing Address Mailing Address
.sD("~~ .T~ ( T1~'l,
CTtY:Slate, Z ' ity, Stale, ZIP
""3)'/""~....,:(l- '(11(01.. \, ~ ~
~nature Date Signature
0j(~~ O{~ L &u6E:r "b\C.1--\'II~l2<b('
Printed Name Printed Name
2.~13 AlJfN....~ 1::: S ~T~ \)!'-
Mailing Addrfls Mailing Address
~lG.o.A r'"," ;1; ',S'l7 l'I\<o-"~""1 7'-r n!'~(r~~~>"
City, State, ZIP City, Stale, ZIP I
"5L~' i. .~~\-S "7/nloL \16) W~~~ _ 7/1710-..-
SIgnature Date Sign'}lur;... Date 1-
1<ct.J1Jf:'t"H- Ct.<>tr'11:l f...?/e3 ~k..r
Printed Name Printed Name
5~1O Iflddellb..-oo/L UJ /'9 2/' ~4/P''y~r'<</'af/4f.t/
MaIling Address Maili~s /
C'rt:.~~I~+'/' To/.. 17573 City,State,~ ~~~z...,.
7~
D te
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 3078, Port Lavaca, TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394
J
.
Page .J2
~
PETITION
Regarding Proposed TNRCC Discharge Permit No. 04001
We, the undersigned and affected citizens, appeal to Ihe Chief clerk of TNRCC, LaDonna Caslanuela, to deliver
our message to Executive Director Jeffrey A. Sailas. We beseech lhe Executive Director:
to grant the request for public meeting concerning the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which was
made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Prolection
Association;
to grant the request for disputed hearing concerning the proposed discharge permit no. 04001, which
was made by leller to the Chief Clerk dated May 2, 2002, from Ken Morris of Carancahua Bay Protection
Association;
~
3. 10 add each of the undersigned altheir address below 10 the TNRCC mailing list conceming proposed
discharge permit no. 04001.
1) (~~7-/80~) :lfJff~
Si ature Date Signature
...:;T"f}(! /( !/Au / U<;d 0 /4.;,1 /f)f/:-ft"'!:f:_
Printed Name Printed Name ./ L '"
//6 U /~ e-<:. 37'3 II !jCCe/VIi/lft #'YJ
Mailing Address Mailing Address /
)?c.l/wOO/-J, zr. 7753/ Itlr;'1J1'fl'tPlf, lir. 77}1()
City, State. ZIP City, Slate, ZIP ,
~3) /g~~~~ 7~!t?-oN)
~-J~~
Printed Name
?P~
Date
Si au!
.leU R,,\, '" ~
Printed Name
'1.,QS \ A\kn.J
Mailing Address
/O<J'23 UL. c..1'l~t!.,)
Mailing Address
C~~:;~I1S '& 77 Sd(
5)~~
- Signature
(:;JR;. ~
Printed Name
h vJre..l, l-r"" -:t bw1
City, State, ZIP
If~J ~~,p ~IU
Mailing Address
p,..l~ n. 7 ?Ort{
City. State, Z~
1~(~~.~ {Jt/Jl.eL,~~
Date ~ature
.;;;J;;;vm.- ,/kt-u ~
Printed Name
d/v~ /U/.... t4U7 ?c.-
Mailing Address
n ~~7X ~y
City, State, ZIP
/0 ~,)
Date
Please return to CBPA, 213 CR 307S, Port Lavaca. TX 77979 or FAX to (361) 893-5394